Join us on Facebook!
Join us in our 24 Hour Chatroom!
Check out on Twitter!
Join us on Instagram

Latest Tweets


  2. We got more from our friends at Budk. This time Rohan is getting some love and specifically Eomer. If you’re a prop…

  3. Hear me out: Animal Crossing, but its Treebeard and you are a sapling Ent arranging your small part of the forest

Exclusive: Bilbo the Brave? Hobbit casting details

September 9, 2010 at 2:12 am by MrCere  - 

We recently got our hands on what we think is some authentic Bilbo casting and production information which seemed to contradict something we knew with absolute certainty: The Hobbit production wanted Martin Freeman for Bilbo and has since as long ago as last year. Seemingly at odds with that fact was apparently concrete casting details about Bilbo and actors still giving audition tapes. Was the role sewn up or not?

A spy has provided an exclusive clue or two about what the role of Bilbo will be like and even a plot detail and a production outline but we were reluctant to report it because of apparent contradictions, but with all the recent Freeman news, it now fits in context. And yes, you have to read on. This is news you must work for, at least a little bit.

Why was the development and production team seeking other actors if the matter was settled? Because Freeman was busy having a career and the MGM situation wasn’t resolved so the film couldn’t move forward. As we all learned recently with Guillermo del Toro being forced to leave the production, having a backup plan is prudent.

Martin’s camp keeps things to itself and we were sworn to secrecy by our unreproachable source but Freeman has been discussed by fans as a potentially great Bilbo for much longer than he was the production’s target, for years even.

So with the Sun, TORn and Entertainment Weekly providing pieces of the puzzle, things are still hopeful for a solution for Freeman.

And what are our secrets? Yes, we have buried the news but according to our spy, if things go well with MGM and Spyglass in the next few weeks, ‘The Hobbit’ will head to production in January, pending negotiations with Freeman and filming could tie up actors for a year. (January happens to be an excellent weather month to shoot at the Hobbiton set.)

And, inadvertently, we know of a possible change to the plot. The character summary says:

although . . . he doesn’t have huge courage he does become, particularly in the last battle, very brave.

As readers will remember, Bilbo is mostly knocked out for “the last battle” which we can assume is The Battle of Five Armies. (That title would mean very little to some actors.) No filmmaker, definitely including producer and probable director Peter Jackson could resist filming and showing such a battle with all its action and emotional wallop, despite the titular character from the source glossing over it (and that is obvious with no spy information at all). But this information is a possible plot reveal that Bilbo will remain conscious and the ‘film Bilbo’ will get to see wonders of battle that ‘book Bilbo’ never did and perhaps play a brave role.

Want more details? Okay. We were further told:

Bilbo is described as “charming . . . is renowned for his dry and quirky sense of humor. There is an appealing vulnerability about him”

That sounds a lot like some of the strengths of Martin Freeman.

The casting team, the trusted folks from the LOTR films, have asked to see self doubts as Bilbo faces the decision to leave the Shire.

Now all of this could be an incorrect or perhaps the casting team has deliberately cast out some misinformation but we do know Freeman was a target and we know there was some trouble in signing and delivering him and it seem likely other options were being explored last week, just in case.

A January production start? We hope so.

Send news tips to or reach the author at

Posted in Casting Rumors, Characters, Director news, Director Rumors, Headlines, Hobbit Book, Hobbit Movie, Locations Sets, MGM, Peter Jackson, Rumors Spy News, Studios, The Hobbit on September 9, 2010 by Exclusive: Bilbo the Brave? Hobbit casting details | Discuss

16 responses to “Exclusive: Bilbo the Brave? Hobbit casting details”

  1. 3blindmice says:

    *fingers crossed* please let everything work out this time! And PJ for director!

  2. Ringwraith111 says:

    oh I HOPE things start moving quickly now and no more problems!

  3. This is no news! Quiet annoying actually! I’m sick and tired of all this bull shit of! Shame!!!

  4. Hi Nick,

    We’re sorry to hear that you don’t enjoy these types of new reports. We would suggest that you self regulate the news that you take in, and thus avoid such a level of frustration.

    As to the merits of this report, the above quotes are direct descriptions of the movie character of Bilbo – this is the first time they have been published and confirmed publicly.

    There are those out there that would appreciate hearing this information as it arrives.

    Thanks for reading, even if you don’t really want to…

  5. Oh, this is so exciting! And just when I was starting to really worry!

    I really hope they can get it together and cast Martin Freeman already. He has been my number one choice since I found out they were going to film The Hobbit, and it’s fantastic to know that the big wigs are on the same page as the fans.

    This news is really restoring my faith in this project. 🙂

  6. Horsegirl says:

    Let the filming begin! We are all anxious for more Extended Edition dvd’s and Complete Soundtracks. Martin Freeman would be an excellent Bilbo, and maybe now the director can gather up the rest of the cast & get us started down the Road that goes Ever Onward.

  7. Albernacchi says:

    Freeman has always been my first choice. I thought of him within **five minutes** of first seriously thinking about who should play the young Bilbo, and without any way of knowing that the production team was thinking along the same lines. Just watch him in “Hitchhiker’s” or “The Good Night” — both very Bilbo-esque roles. Here’s hoping the schedule works out.
    BTW, the “self-doubt” on leaving Hobbiton is consistent with the book, IMO.

  8. Nda002 says:

    I think Dominic West ( McNulty from HBO’s The Wire) would make an amazing Bilbo. He is by far the most qualified in my opinion.

  9. Anon says:

    Martin Freeman would be an appalling choice for Bilbo! What aspect of his past work even begins to suggest he could take on the role of Bilbo as, initially, a country-side based, genial villager?
    Freeman’s persona and acting style shouts modern, urban, and thirty-something Generation X slacker, often with a faint whiff of sleaze in his characters.
    Think of Ian Holm who fit the role so well: could Freeman ever grow into Ian Holm? I really cannot see it.

  10. PleasePleaseGetAGoodBilbo says:

    That is a very good point indeed. I don’t know who is best for Bilbo (Martin Freeman would be awful: might be a nice chap, but a poor actor). Dominic West would be a surprise choice – but he could do it. Good actor, for one thing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *