I was just told that you wanted reviews from dvd screening. Hope you find this useful. I am still totally blown away and thought that as a nearly 48-year old, there wasn’t much left that could do this to me.
The word “WOW !” will be a large part of my vocabulary for days to come. 😉
I was one of the fortunate few to win passes to a digital screeening of the DVD from Moviefone. It was shown at the Cinemark Legacy theater in Plano, TX, which happens to be the closest theater to my home. I am blessed!
I asked my friend, Dandy Baggins to go with me and we shared an experience that will last a lifetime! I will not say what the additions were because I do not like spoilers, myself.
I will say that all of the additions added greatly to the story and filled in blanks that really should have been filled originally. New Line should be ashamed that they were so uptight about that 3 hour time.
I just want to say that this was not an ordinary screening. This was a digital remaster or whatever it’s called and with digital sound! It was like seeing the movie for the first time!(even though i had seen it 19 times thatrically before and at least 10 times at home.)
Dandy and I cried and held each other for most of it it was so amazing! The new stuff is fantastic and very well done. PJ said that things weren’t as smooth, but that is debatable.
I don’t know if there are any plans to release this to the general public in theaters, but I highly, HIGHLY recommend that everyone write to New Line and ask that it be done!
Hi, I went to the FOTR: EE screening in NYC and loved every minute of it (all 210 of ’em!) Regarding the new cut, it’s a lot more like the book than the original film was – funnier, livelier, and much more focused on the minutiae of middle earth. However, I wouldn’t say it’s better – just different.
They showed the latest trailer for TTT prior to the film, to the cheers and claps of all – including Richard Taylor (who I was sitting one row in front of!) Seeing FOTR on the big screen one last time was a great introduction to this new version, and I can’t thank AOL/New Line/Moviefone enough!
Amazing is all I can say! More character development, more humor, and more warmth. It just added to the whole experience of the film.
I especially loved what it added to the relationships built in the story. You understand more about the Frodo/Bilbo, Gimli/Galadriel relationships, not to mention others. You can feel the intimacy building in the Fellowship in this film version.
I especially loved the Lothlorien sequence in the extended edition. It gave more of the impression I had from the book than the theatrical version did. Lorien felt less spooky and surreal. It still carried a majestic aura but felt warmer and more inviting. The elves (especially Galadriel) were able to show a personable, caring side. The gift giving scenes were great!
I won’t write everything I could say but just sum it up as “Thanks PJ for giving us this version” and to those that are debating on the purchase of this version “It is so worth it!”
It’s the morning after my screening of LOTR: SE at the Loew’s Boston Common in Boston MA. All I can say is WOW. My mind is so full of new and different images. I can’t wait to see the movie again and again.
What did I love? The list is too numerous but here are the highlights in the order in which my brain remembers them. 1.) The new and very amusing opening with Bilbo’s description of Hobbits and the Shire. Very charming. 2.) Hobbits singing and partying at the Green Dragon. Need I say more? 3.) Elrond’s farewell at Rivendell and the very funny moment at the end of the new scene. Left or right Gandalf (snerk). 4.) Boromir, Merry, and Pippin practicing and the tossing of Aragorn (this still makes me giggle) 5.) Every new moment in Lorien was amazing, Celeborn had a wonderfully expanded role which made him seem far less the dullard in the theatrical cut. Gimli snoring (too funny). Sam’s poem (very sweet). The new lembas scene (still laughing). Boromir’s kind words to Frodo when everyone else was embarrassed and shocked (wonderful). The gift giving scene was absolutely beautiful and charming (it should have been in the theatrical cut). 6.) Aragorn and Boromir arguing. It made Boromir’s death scene so much more poignant. 7.) Merry and Pippin’s new role during the final battle scene. It was appropriate that they help Boromir take down as many orcs as possible. Not just stand there with stunned expressions.
While watching the movie I had the vague feeling that many of the scenes were different somehow. Either recut, shot from a different angle or with a different close-up. I’ll need to see the movie a few more times before I can say with certainty which scenes were different (oh the sacrifices….grin).
The only scene that did not work for me was Aragorn’s new scene at Rivendell when he and Elrond are at Aragorn’s mother’s grave. They were talking about Aragorn’s destiny and the re-forged sword and then there was an abrupt cut to Sting. For a moment I laughed thinking that Sting was Narsil re-forged.
I think LOTR: SE is wonderful and just improves upon an already brilliant movie. I thank Moviefone and New Line for allowing us to see the movie on a big screen with awesome surround sound. I hope next year they’ll decide to release the SE on the big screen for the general public. I’d love to see it again in all it’s glory.
My husband and I were at the EE showing last night at McClurg Court in downtown Chicago. It wasn’t nearly as packed as we had expected! We got right in, and had great seats, even though we didn’t make it to the theatre until half an hour before the show.
As for the film itself – it was amazing. Lots of details from the book were there, and pretty much all of the male characters gained a good deal of depth from the extra screen time. Some fans will be glad to hear that Celeborn, especially, benefits from some extra time, and more lines!
This edition is just fantastic, and I can hardly wait to see it again next week, in my own home. But seeing it in a digital, THX theatre was an amazing experience. Well worth the trouble and the trip!
A friend and I attended the free showing at the Loews Cineplex on 34th Street in Manhattan. We got there about 5:40 PM for a 6 PM show and thought we were in the wrong place when we didn’t see a line of people.
Further confusing us was the long line across the street at the Manhattan Center (opera house/theater), which was actually for a People magazine event with Justin Timberlake. It turned out that, on the 2nd floor landing of the Loews, there was a table set up where staffers were checking e-mail addresses against the printouts we brought along.
We each got a ticket for a free soda and popcorn bag and were directed to theater 7, (I assume) the largest one in the multiplex. At first, we were told we could only sit in the first four rows or the last three, and that the middle eight rows were reserved.
I counted wrong and we sat in the last of the “reserved” rows, but 10 minutes later the same guy told everyone that we could sit anywhere. Since we were right in the middle of the theater, we stayed put. The most disappointing thing about the whole evening was that the theater wasn’t that crowded. It was about 3/4 full, which wasn’t bad, but I had expected to fight for seats, especially in Manhattan. A few minutes after 6, the projector came on and we were treated to a DLP version of the full TTT trailer. Then, with no further ads or trailers, the FOTR extended version started.
Overall, we agreed that the added footage improved the movie. I liked the original opening, but I thought that Bilbo’s introduction of hobbits and The Shire was effective and charming. Throughout the movie, the additions helped to clarify character motivations or explain events of the story that were only alluded to in the original version.
The gifts scene in Lothlorien might have been the most effective addition; we both really enjoyed Gimli’s hesitation and embarrassment with Galadriel. A few bits seemed thrown in just for geeks like us, such as Gandalf’s line about Smeagol being Gollum’s real name.
I expected the movie to feel like it was 3 1/2 hours long, and it did, though I was never bored even though this was my fourth viewing. The digital projection was clear, the colors bright and crisp, and the sound was outstanding. I can’t wait to see this version again on DVD next week. And I’m even more excited now for TTT next month.
