And they are still floating in.. ichi also attended the concert and was fortunate enough to shake hands with Howard Shore himself after the show!

The concert had been going since 3 with other acts, but we were only interested in Howard so we didn’t go in until the last interval. We took our seats and waited.

The London Philamonic began to take their seats, once they were in place a boys choir came in the back, closely followed by a male choir and finally a female choir. Then the moment we were all waiting for Howard Shore came onto the stage to a fantastic response, the applause went on for ages. Howard was clearly flattered.

Everyone settled down and it begun, from the moment the female choir began ‘The Prophecy’ my draw dropped, it was really happening and the sound was just a joy to hear. The Prophecy was more in keeping with the film than what we hear on the CD, I have to say I do prefer that version. The whole sound was mindblowing, I’d say it was CD quality, but it wasn’t, it was better than that, mindblowing!

It then smoothly went into Concerning Hobbits, this was the moment I had been really looking forward to above anything else, I adore the strings in that track and throughout the build up to the day that was foremost in my mind. I wasn’t to be dissapointed. The emotions were really running high by now, you know that feeling you get in your chest when you’re about to cry? It was all pure joy, I don’t think I’ve ever witnessed live music and felt like that, with the possible exception of David Bowie at Glastonbury a few years ago.

I’m not sure if it was just me enjoying it too much, but we seem to get to Rivendell really quickly if you get my meaning. the whole Black Rider, knife in the Dark, flight to the ford sequence was quite abridged. Not that it was the slightest bit bad, just a bit quick. Howard cleverly hinted to the bits with enya, the whole Rivendell part was beautiful, especially the rousing Fellowship theme that comes in when frodo says ‘I will take the ring to mordor’ That bit is probably my favorite part of the film, pretty much because of what the soundtrack does, I will never forget that sound.

Then the big surprise for me, the Moria Sequence. Yes I’ve always liked it, but I’ve prefered other parts of the score more. I don’t know what it was or why but this whole section affected me more than the rest of the concert, cue the tears, and it wasn’t in the usual ‘gandalf falling moment’ If I remember correctly it was when they got into the great hall. Then the big solo after the fall. Obviously this was one of the big expectations of the concert, and the kid singing was clearly nervous as hell. But all credit to him he hit the notes perfectly, sure he didn’t hold on to them quite as long as the original but it was still a great performance.

‘Lament’ of course was beautiful, The female soloist was stunning, and the way her voice linked with the Sitar (I think that was what it was I couldn’t see it properly) was incredible, a real other worldly sound without any digital effects. By this stage I was totally overwhelmed by the whole experience, every note from all the different instruments was such a pleasure to the ears. The last few songs were wonderful (Amon Hen inparticular but I’ll mention that later) building up to the climactic finale with ‘In dreams’ The young soloists nerves seem to have calmed and he did a fantastic job of it, with the orchestra and the choirs working off his voice it created such a fantastic ending, it was no surprise that Howard and the LPO recieved a standing ovation and Howard came back on stage three times, boy did they deserve it.

So that was it, it was over. we were left with an incredible mix of emotions from joy to bemused disbelief that we’d actually just witnessed that incredible display. It really provided and insight in to the genius of the man, he conducts with such incredible passion you can see the love with every movement of his arms. And how he came up with the ideas to create some of the sounds is beyond me, for instance stroking some sort of asian cymbal with a violin, created the most bizarre screeching sound that was perfect for moria. Or during Amon Hen, listen carefully to the CD, you can hear what is like the sound of armour clincking but it seems musical somehow. Well that was the percussionist with metal chain wrapped around her hand, hitting the open strings of a harpsichord (not a piano as reported elsewhere). If you ever get the chance for the love of god go and see it, I’m desperately hoping that I will be here next year reporting on the TT concert.

Well that was it, time to go home, but there was one last highlight remaining…………….

Time to head to the station then, thinking the day was over. We were heading for the station and we had to walk round the back of the hall to get there. I suddenly noticed a group of posh cars waiting, members of the choir, people walking away with harp shaped cases and a group of ‘rings’ fans. Obviously we’d stumbled upon the artist’s exit, so we stuck around. We hadn’t planned on making an effort to get an autograph, but we’d had brought with us the special edition TT soundtrack just in case. It seemed it was worth it.

We waited quite a while, and it was freezing, still a dedicated fan must do what a dedicated fan must do. Once all the choir and orchestra members had gone it was just a small group of fans waiting. We started chatting to another couple, no idea who they were but hey, I’m a talkative kinda person. One of them was grilling Howard’s chauffer for information The grilling was successful, we were now getting good information when he’d be out.

Then we saw him through the window, and he was out. No mad panic up to him, everyone just calmly walked up to him and he seemed more than happy to stay for a while and not. He chatted with everyone, stood in for photos (I’m still annoyed I didn’t bring my camera!:grr and signed anything that was put infront of him. When it was our turn, he signed my cd book, we had a short chat, congratulated him on the concert etc, thanked him and that was it. Brief but unforgettable, and a perfect end to a perfect day. Howard is a genius and a really nice person to boot, and kindly added his name to my growing LOTR autograph collection.

Our second lesson on “How to Construct a Sindarin Sentence”, which concentrated on articles, took place Wednesday, Feb 12 in #TheHallofFire. We’d like to thank our guest, Barliman’s regular and self-taught language expert Elostrion. Here’s the transcript of the log:

[Elostrion] Welcome to “How to Construct a Sindarin Sentence: Lesson Two”
[Elostrion] We will be covering Articles.
[Elostrion] They are very simple.
[Elostrion] In Sindarin, there are no indefinate articles (a, an).
[Elostrion] Only definate (the).
[Elostrion] However, there are four forms of “the”.
[Elostrion] Sindarin “the” has two distinct divisions:
[Elostrion] Singular and Plural
[Elostrion] Each has a seperate particle article and a suffix form.
[Elostrion] Singular:
[Elostrion] The Sindarin Singular “the” is “i, -n”
[Elostrion] The “i” stands alone
[Elostrion] The “-n” is suffixed onto the preceding word.
[Elostrion] Obviously, if there is no word preceding the article, than we cannot use the suffix form.
[Elostrion] I prefer to use the suffix form in all cases I am able.
[Elostrion] However, be careful not to suffix onto consonants that cannot be followed by an “n”, e.g. “m, etc.”
[Elostrion] Plural:
[Elostrion] “in, -in”
[Elostrion] The same rules apply.
[Elostrion] We have more liberty with the suffix “-in” because it begins with a vowel.
[Elostrion] As I stated last lesson, Sindarin articles always precede their noun.
[Elostrion] Here are a few examples:
[Elostrion] The bull…
[Elostrion] We would use a singular article, becuase there is only one bull.
[Elostrion] And since “the” is not preceded by another word, we have only one choice…
[Elostrion] “I vund…”
[Elostrion] …abandon the birds…
[Elostrion] We would use a plural article, because there is more than one bird.
[Elostrion] “…awartha i filig…”
[Elostrion] The change in the article is explained by Consonant Mutation, which we will cover soon.
[Elostrion] We have also another choice…
[Elostrion] “…awarthan filig…”
[Elostrion] I am ready to take questions
[Elwen] i would just like to now if the same consonants apply in Sindarin as in Quenya as far as not being able to suffix -n to them
[Elostrion] There are of course different rules that apply; however, in this case, most are concurrent between the two languages. Such as:
[Elostrion] ‘b’
[Elostrion] ‘l’
[Elostrion] etc.
[Elostrion] Next question please.
[JulieOh] is the article always required, or can it be understood? e.g., would “I like books” have to be translated to “I like the books”?
[Elostrion] Sindarin is unique in that you have quite a bit of freedom on matters like these.
[Elostrion] In situations such as Noun Declinsion and such the article is always understood.
[Elostrion] It is more common to write the article; however, if it is not wanted/needed you may leave it out.
[Elaran] question: we dont have any examples of a article being suffixed to the word before it. only combined with prepostions….
[Elostrion] That is true; however, this theory arised after many years of hard study and a collaboration of minds.
[jincey] could you tell us who the scholars are?
[Elostrion] We have come to the conclusion that it is probably possible to do so.
[Elostrion] Ryzsard J. Derdzinski is a wonderful mind
[Elostrion] As is Helge E. Fauskanger
[Elostrion] And, of course, we cannot forget David Salo, the leading Elvish expert in the world.
[Elaran] ask : why do you believe that it is possible?
[Elostrion] I have come to trust these men over my studies. I have not delved too deep into the issue myself, seeing it as already resolved.
[Arodriel] wheres the best place to find verbs in elvish?
[Elostrion] ardalambion.com, run by Helge Fauskanger, has a wonderful new page up with suggested conjugations of Sindarin verbs…
[Elostrion] however, I am not sure I agree with everything that is contained inside.
[Elostrion] The document is not perfect. Don’t take it as canon.
[Elostrion] Another question?
[Eravial] question: could you give us a couple more examples of plural artcle usage?
[Elostrion] Absolutely!
[Elostrion] “The bulls…”
[Elostrion] “I vund…”
[Elostrion] Again the change is explained by consonant mutation
[Elostrion] Is there another?
[Darkfyre] Question: Is there an example that doesn’t use consonant mutation?
[Elostrion] LoL
[Elostrion] “The strikes…”
[Elostrion] “In draimm…”
[Elostrion] Are there any more?
[jincey] i think we are ready to open the floor now. Looks like there is some debate on what is canon and what is conjecture : )
[Elostrion] Thank you all for coming…I hope to see you next week.
[Raven_Tindomiel] thanks, Elostrion
[happy_eirien] will we be learning characters during these lessons?
[JulieOh] thanks Elostrion! Can’t wait for next week
[Thevina] Argh!
[Not_Maedhros] What is the article “ir” for?
[Menelmacar] thank you very much
[Halladaliel] thanks
[Elostrion] It is my pleasure Raven
[Darkfyre] thanks Elostrion
[aislinn] thanks!
[Eravial] thank you
[happy_eirien] thanx
[Thevina] Elostrian… I am so sorry I missed your class! πŸ™
[Arodriel] whats the next lesson gonna be on?
[Jeremy] can someone give an example of Singular articles usage?
Not_Maedhros is unhappy that he missed it.
[Elostrion] LoL, u-moe edaved.
[TheRedSunRises] 3Cuio nin mellon Elostrion
[TheRedSunRises] and thanks!
[Elaran] Elostrion… we have examples of -in being used with a plual subject, Fauskanger notes this, any comments?
[Elostrion] Excuse my lack of accents.
[Elaran] sorry Singular subject
[Elaran] _erin dolothen ethuil_ on the eight day……
[Lembas_n_Cram] thanks Elostrion!
[Elaran] I do not think it is safe to assume that we can use -in in reference to plural subjects only
Thevina the incredibly behind the times asks if these lessons will be each Wednesday?
[Elostrion] There are very many attested examples like this, applying to different areas. Tolkien kept changing his mind about Sindarin, so it is hard to see which version is the final.
[Elassar] am i the only one who can’t understand elvish?
[Not_Maedhros] Nope
[tigere47] no
[Eravial] no
[Elaran] Yes but Fauskanger says that no rule can be reached
[Arodriel] no
[Not_Maedhros] I cannot understand… most of it.
[Not_Maedhros] Hehe…
[aislinn] i am getting there
[Primula_Hornblower1] no Elassar
[Guest] i can say some basic words
[Elostrion] That is true to some extent
[Elaran] yet you presented it as if it was fact that -in was used in reference to a plular subject
[Not_Maedhros] Elostrion, what is the difference between present tense form of say… gâr and garir?
[happy_eirien] will we learn how to use characters?
[Not_Maedhros] happy_eirien, chgaracters?
[Not_Maedhros] If you mean the Tengwar, I can help you there…
[Elassar] when’s the next lesson?
[Arodriel] and what is it on?
[happy_eirien] cool!
[Eravial] will the lesson be posted like the first one?
[Elaran] garir means “they hold” gar means “hold”
[Elostrion] Every Wednesday at 7:00pmEST
[Smoky] Elostrion…could you tell me what mutation to use in a phrase like “leaves of the trees” ??
[Thevina] thank you, Elostrion! next week I won’t miss it altogether…
[Elostrion] Smoky, e-mail me and I will be glad to help.
Not_Maedhros feels sorry for poor Elsortion
[Guest] is the lesson over
[Elaran] Elostrion, in your example _i vund_ you used lenition instead of nasal mutation… any comments?
[Smoky] ok ….thanks !!!
[jincey] we are taking general questions now
[Elostrion] In fact, if any of you have any questions, feel free to e-mail me at elostrion@hotmail.com
[Guest] ok
[Thevina] Really? You don’t mind being inundated?
[Arodriel] what a nice boy
[Thevina] I’m translating an English phrase to Sindarin, using a PDF Sindarin dictionary…
[Primula_Hornblower1] πŸ˜€
[Elostrion] Hiswelokë!
[Primula_Hornblower1] thats cool Thevina
[Elaran] Elostrion – whose theory is it exactly that you can suffic -n to the end of the previous word?
[Elaran] *suffix
[Thevina] Thanks, Primula. It sounded Elvish even in English- wanted to translate it for her for fun. Plus I was sure it would look gorgeous in Tengwar.
[Arodriel] is there a book souly based on how to speak elvish?
[Guest] elostrion, are you the teacher
[Elaran] Elostrion???
[Primula_Hornblower1] Tengwar is not easy
[Elostrion] I am Guest
[Elostrion] I pm’d you Elaran
[Guest] oh ok
[Elaran] uh, how do I check pms?
[Thevina] Tengwar isn’t too bad… just put the symbols to the right in Sindarin, to the left or right above in Quenya… basically…
[Elostrion] Arodriel, there are none available in the US
[Thevina] (to represent vowels, that is)
[Arodriel] that stinks
[Arodriel] write one
[Elassar] is there any books I can find that teaches Sindarin
[Arodriel] πŸ™‚
[Elassar] ?
[Thevina] There are some online lessons for Quenya, if memory serves…
[Elassar] where?
[Elostrion] Elassar, there are no reliable books on the shelf
[Thevina] A chap in Finland has them.
[Thevina] sorry… that’s probably not very helpful! πŸ˜›
[Arodriel] how much longer are you gonna be on Elostrion?
[Elostrion] A few minutes
[Guest] there are some basics for tengwar and some other stuuf in the back of the book the return of the king
[Thevina] Okay… Elostrion, thank you, and I’ll be here on time next week.
[Arodriel] same
[Tauriel] Online Quenya lessons are at http://ardalambion.com
[Guest] same
[Arodriel] i had to babysit and i missed it yet again
[Thevina] Tauriel!
[Tauriel] Hi πŸ™‚
[Arodriel] i gotta go eat so thanks elostrion, namarie!
[Elostrion] You’re welcome
[tigere47] namarie arodiel
[Elostrion] Navaer mellyn nîn!
[Elassar] thank you!
[Halladaliel] thanks again and see you week!
Lembas_n_Cram opens the door, waves, and walks out into the night
Elostrion has left #thehalloffire

IRVINE, Calif. – JANUARY 22, 2003 – Blizzard Entertainment®, a division of Vivendi Universal Games, announced today plans for Warcraft® III: The Frozen Throne?, the expansion set to the fastest selling PC game ever*, Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos?. Since the game’s release in July 2002, Warcraft III has now surpassed 2 million units sold worldwide. *

“We are very pleased by the success of Warcraft III,” said Mike Morhaime, Blizzard Entertainment president and co-founder. “Our plans for the expansion set include increasing the strategic gameplay possibilities and depth of the Warcraft universe by introducing a wide array of new Heroes and units, specifically designed to enhance each race.”

Following in the tradition of previous Blizzard expansion sets, Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne provides gamers with a vast new chapter in the epic Warcraft saga. In the single-player campaign, players revisit the war-torn world of Azeroth. Several months have passed since Archimonde and the Burning Legion were defeated at the battle of Mount Hyjal, yet a new threat has arisen throughout the land.

The evil Lich King Ner’zhul has been imprisoned inside the Icecrown glacier, deep within the arctic continent of Northrend. Although the former Orc Shaman lacks physical form, his soul lives on, forever seeking a means to escape his icy prison. As the saga continues, it is revealed that both the Night Elf renegade, Illidan, and the traitorous Death Knight, Arthas, seek the Icecrown glacier and the mysterious powers found inside. While it is uncertain as to what is being sought inside the icy tomb, players must traverse uncharted lands and battle treacherous new enemies to uncover the schemes of these nefarious beings, and save all of Azeroth from the forces of darkness.

Key features include:

– One new Hero per race, each possessing powerful spells and magical abilities specifically designed to enhance each race

– A host of new units, each equipped with new abilities and spells, giving players the opportunity to create diverse strategic and tactical forms of combat

– 3 new tilesets featuring extraordinary new lands to explore, complete with numerous creeps and critters to wage war upon

– Player-built shops, unique for each race, equipped with items carefully designed to improve and aid the units of every race

– Neutral buildings, which will provide players with numerous new upgrades, items and abilities

– Neutral Heroes, available for recruitment by all players, that can supplement and strengthen a player’s army with all new spells and abilities

– An advanced world editor that allows players to create their own custom campaigns, complete with cut-scenes and voiceovers

– Many new multiplayer maps

– Expanded multiplayer options over Battle.net® including multiple new game types, clan and tournament support

Warcraft III: The Frozen Throne is currently slated for worldwide release in the summer of 2003, and is expected to retail for approximately $35.00. The game is expected to receive a Teen Rating from the ESRB.

Since its debut in 1994, the #1-selling Warcraft series has won industry acclaim and has shattered sales records worldwide with over 8 million copies sold. In 1995, Blizzard followed the well-received Warcraft: Orcs and Humans? with the critically acclaimed Warcraft II: Tides of Darkness?, which won multiple Game of the Year awards and is still considered by many critics to be one of the best games ever made.

Best known for blockbuster hits including the Warcraft, StarCraft®, and Diablo® series, Blizzard Entertainment (www.blizzard.com), a division of Vivendi Universal Games, is a premier developer and publisher of entertainment software renowned for creating many of the industry’s most critically acclaimed games. Blizzard’s track record includes seven #1-selling games and multiple Game of the Year awards. The company’s free Internet gaming service Battle.net reigns as the largest in the world, with millions of active users.

WASHINGTON — Actor Sean Astin and wrestler Bradshaw are among celebrities who are using their stardom to increase troop morale and keep the military fresh in the minds of Americans.

Astin, who is known for his roles in “Rudy” and the “Lord of the Rings,” visited the Pentagon Jan. 30 to record public service announcements thanking troops for their service and re-emphasizing America’s trust in its military.

He also narrated an announcement to promote the Criminal Investigation Command, commonly known as CID, and asked interested soldiers to apply to the command if they are interested in becoming a CID Special Agent.

“There’s a lot of different people and voices in America, and I don’t mind letting my voice be heard,” Astin said during an interview conducted at the Pentagon. “I learned from reading about Vietnam that no matter what you think politically about certain deployments, as a good citizen and a patriot it’s your duty to appreciate that there are soldiers using their lives on your behalf as a citizen.”

Although many may know that Astin has appeared in more than 25 motion pictures, few know that he has served as a civilian aide to the secretary of the Army since 1995. He served under Togo West, Louis Caldera and now the current Secretary of the Army Thomas White.

For protocol purposes Astin, as a civilian aide, is ranked just below a three-star general and is considered to be the secretary of the Army’s personal representative in the California region. Part of the basis of a CASA’s appointment is his ability to increase the public’s understanding of the Army, and Astin said he tells the Army story to anyone who wants to know it.

“I’m in a position where I do whatever I can to support the Army,” Astin said. “I’ve visited installations, and took the time to write ‘thank-you’ letters to business who had reserve-component soldiers to be mobilized.”

In an unofficial capacity, Bradshaw has conducted countless interviews, worn Army apparel on TV and used his weekly program sponsored by World Wrestling Enterprise as a venue to talk about how the war is affecting its troops.

Bradshaw visited the Pentagon Feb. 4 and soldiers at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Washington, D.C., who are recovering from wounds inflicted while supporting Operation Enduring Freedom. He was one of three performers who accompanied Sgt. Maj. of the Army Jack Tilley on a USO tour to Afghanistan, Uzbekistan and Kuwait during the Christmas holiday.

“During the USO trip, I told Sergeant Major Tilley that I regret not being a soldier,” Bradshaw said. “He told me that, ‘everyone has to find his own role and do what he can to support troops.'”

Both in and out of the ring, Bradshaw said his niche is telling Americans what life is like for soldiers on enemy territory.

“Video games have gotten so realistic now a lot of times people believe that soldiers are in some type of high-tech video game over there. That’s not the case, we’re putting men and women in the way of bullets.

“Despite the fact the Army does everything outstandingly well to take care of these soldiers, they’re still out in the desert, away from families, and I don’t care if they’re staying in the Hilton, it’s no place they want to be.”

In the future, Bradshaw said he wants to film public service announcements also.

Astin’s announcements will be seen on Armed Forces Radio and Television Stations.

Over double the number of stores participating from last year (over 450 for 2003). Over 5,000 entries!

Here’s the Timeline to keep you in the loop.

HEAT 1 – Local
Now! – Thousands of hobbyists are putting the finishing touches on their models as we speak in preparation for this weekend’s judging. Saturday, Feb 15 – The end of the first Heat sees the judging of all THREE categories. Winners move on to the STATE finals and HEAT 2.

HEAT 2 – State
Saturday, March 1 – The three winners from each shop travel to their state’s HEAT 2 representative. Winners from this round are the 3 best painted The Two Towers painted miniatures in their state! A real honor in itself.

HEAT 3 – Regional
Saturday, March 29 – Things start to get really serious now! There are only SEVEN regional judging sites in the entire country. The winners from this round will move on to the NATIONAL finals!

HEAT 3 – Nationals
Friday, April 18 – GWUSA Headquarters – Glen Burnie Battle Bunker sees the National Finals of the 2003 LotR National Painting Competition! If you are in the area, be sure to stop by and congratulate all the entries.

All the latest news and information will be Posted in:

Share: Divide line

A few days ago we posted Teri’s letter which was a spirited defense of the way Faramir was portrayed in the movies. Though I received a great many emails that agreed enthusiastically with her point of view, it’s well worth posting some of the many rebuttals we also received.

With Faramir we have an example of a theme in the books that the filmmakers decided to change, namely the contrast between Faramir’s incorruptibility and strong will, and his brother Boromir’s fatal flaw. I think the most important point people offered was this: Tolkien wanted to make it clear that a strong will and pure heart COULD resist the Ring. PJ’s team decided to elaborate a different strand: That Mankind is particularly susceptible to the Ring for, as it says in the prologue to FOTR it is Men ‘who above all things, desire Power.’ Not everyone thinks this change serves the story well, and I’m posting some of their points below; I hope the writers will forgive me that I’ve edited them a bit.

Felgund writes, “Okay, for me the whole Faramir issue comes down to one thing: the action he takes regarding the Ring. I’m not concerned with the “color” of his character/actions, because that can be a matter of perception — whose eyes we are viewing him through. Every action Faramir takes BEFORE gaining knowledge of the Ring can, in my opinion, be “tweaked” with no serious damage to his character. Osgiliath (with the intent to take Frodo & Sam to Minas Tirith) could have easily replace Henneth Annun as a destination — as long as he didn’t know about the Ring before hand. As soon as knowledge of the Ring is revealed to him, his entire character is shaped by his response to that knowledge.

“The point is (to rebut Teri) that Faramir *doesn’t* do what you or I, or Boromir, or “anyone” might have done. Even Boromir had underlying noble intentions for wanting the Ring — to save his city. Faramir’s character is made manifest by the fact that (in the book) he is not even tempted to take the Ring. He does not need to be shown the right path (as with the ridiculous face-off between Frodo & the Nazgul in the movie) — he *knows* what the right thing to do is and he does it. No questions asked. It is no more in his nature to take the Ring than it is in mine to torture children & small animals (which , I assure you, it isn’t!) He is able to see the Bigger Picture.”

Robert in Colorado writes, “Peter Jackson has done a lot of damage to the Tolkien philosphy and message in the book when he sought to reinterpret the character of Faramir. Some try to defend this misinterpretation based on the length of the movie. However. he could easily have cut out the parts where Strider falls over the cliff (which is nowhere in the book) in order to get the “time” to interpret Faramir correctly.

“…One of the major themes in LOTR is the ability of the good characters to realize the consequences of their actions, and it is this realization that gives them the strength to resist the temptation. The Jackson interpretation of Faramir does not allow any such foresight on the part of the character. In the movie one does not even know why Faramir lets Frodo go. Faramir simply watches an encounter between Frodo and a Ringwraith, and because of this, he lets them go. The question is Why? Jackson does not give us any answers consistent with Tolkien philosophy.

“Finally, the characters Faramir/Boromir in the book gives us two different psychological profiles that complement each other. With Boromir one can find hope that even though one can “fall” into the temptation of the Ring he can “redeem” himself if he does not fall too far. With Faramir one can find the hope that when temptation comes one can successfully resist it.”

Tiel argued that the theme of faith and trust was very important to Tolkien, and didn’t deserve to be excised from the movie: “People have been arguing that Faramir’s behavior in the movie is what you would _logically_ expect from a war captain who comes across two suspicious characters in enemy territory, while his behavior in the book is unrealistic. I agree this is probably true. But Tolkien would have known that; he was a soldier after all.

“One of the themes that continually runs through LOTR, particularly in the later sections, is the contrast between decisions based on logic and decisions based on faith. From an objective (“logical”) point of view, the quest of the Ring really is pretty hopeless– Boromir is right when he refers to the plan as absurd. Similarly, Denethor’s despair in RotK is perfectly logical: Gondor could not possibly survive against Mordor by force of arms. “Despair” is a key word here, because to a Catholic like Tolkien, despair is a profound sin.

“If logic leads to despair, what are the grounds for hope? Elrond and Gandalf both tell Frodo that he was meant to be the Ring-bearer, and that this is a hopeful thing. Why? Because it means that _someone_ up there (Iluvatar himself, or one of the Valar– it comes to the same thing in the end) is guiding events, and it’s not the will of this being that Sauron should succeed. So we’re not in this alone, and we’ve received pretty clear indications that supporting Frodo in his quest– no matter how illogical it may seem– is the right thing to do. This is an awfully big leap of faith. Boromir is not willing to take it. Denethor in his turn rejects it. But Faramir accepts it, even though logic would tell him that letting the hobbits take the Ring towards Mordor is the height of folly.

“I believe Tolkien meant to contrast Boromir and Faramir, and later Denethor and Faramir, in terms of Faramir’s willingness to be guided by faith. I think this has gotten lost in the movie. (Let me pause here and note that I’m not myself religious: however Tolkien was, and I think that should be taken into account whenever we think about what he may have intended. Overall I think that Peter Jackson and his team have shied away from this aspect of Tolkien.) I believe that humility is what allows Faramir to be so guided, rather than an arrogant trust in his own reason– for an example of his humility, compare his reaction to Aragorn with Denethor’s and Boromir’s (Boromir in the book never really comes around to accepting Aragorn’s claim to kingship, and we can only speculate how events would have gone if Aragorn had arrived at Minas Tirith while B. and D. were both still alive).

“Finally, I’d like to take issue with Teri’s claim that Faramir knows nothing about the Ring. Faramir was Gandalf’s pupil while Gandalf was in Minas Tirith researching the history of the Ring: he inferred that Isildur took it from Sauron’s hand at the battle of the Last Alliance, and he seems to have known a great deal about its properties– enough to make the “not if I found it by the highway” statement before he even knows where it is. And once Sam reveals the presence of the Ring, Faramir realizes the implications immediately. Unlike Boromir, he doesn’t have to be told that it’s not possible to wield the Ring without turning to evil.”

Natasha mourns the loss of another of Tolkien’s themes: “There are many themes that run through the book, and I suppose every reader would have some that he’d place more emphasis on than others. For me, I have to say that the words of Galadriel (I think) that the travellers would find friends in unexpected places, represents a big theme. There will always be those who oppose evil, and wherever we/they may go we/they may encounter such allies unexpectedly. To me, in the book, the whole Faramir episode,(coming right after the whole desolation in front of the Morranon bit, and with the growing weight of the ring and the evil of the environs of Mordor becoming ever more palpable to both Frodo and the reader) offers a respite from all the perils that the hobbits face and from the heaviness of their burden. As is Ithilien, so is this whole episode a relief from the evil of Mordor, and a break well needed in order to make it possible for the hobbits – and me as I read – to continue. To therefore have it cruelly turned into yet another trial for Frodo and Sam, is my chief objection to this change, great cinematography though it may be.”

ElanortheEldest replies to Teri’s points one by one; here are some:

Teri: Faramir in the movie was a little more stern and moody in his attitude, and took the hobbits with him to Gondor. What’s the big deal? Why is everyone freaking out about it? The changes are very minor and don’t really take away from the story, so why is everyone getting all bent out of shape over it?

ElanortheEldest: “These changes affect both Faramir’s character _and_ the story. Faramir of the book was never interested in the Ring, no matter what the reason. Having him march the hobbits to Osgiliath would never have entered his mind – not to mention marching them roughly along & not even bothering to answer their pleas. If, as you say, he were only interested in saving Gondor, and no evil thought occurred to him, then why could he not explain this to Frodo & Sam?

“This change affects the story in another way: it was essential to the success of the quest that the whereabouts of the Ring be kept secret. Now that we have Frodo just about putting on the Ring in front of the Nazgul (another drastic change, I might add) we are left with two equally dissatisfying alternatives:

1 – Sauron now knows where the Ring is, which will mean a mucking up of more events in RotK

or

2 – The Nazgul didn’t even see the Ring, which would make him much less evil than he really is.”

Teri: Number one, in Tolkien’s original portrayal of Faramir in the book, he was kind and gentle to the hobbits…” and “He was never too suspicious to begin with, and befriended them immediately.”

EtheE: “Here is the first area where I’m not sure you looked closely at the book. Consider:

“… make haste to declare yourselves and your errand,’ said Faramir. ‘We have work to do, and this is no time or place for riddling or parleying. Come! Where is the third of your company?… the skulking fellow that we saw with his nose in the ool down younder. He had an ill-favoured loko. Some sying breed of Orc, I guess.’

Or – “… a strange stern look came into his face.”

“Later he questions Frodo hard about his mission. All this does not denote softness, but a fair-minded attitude that we don’t get in the movie (apart from the fact the Ring was evil, it would _never_ have been his to use).”

Teri: “He was not evil and did absolutely nothing wrong in the movie. People act as though he tortured Frodo and Sam and treated them like dirt, but that’s not the case! ”

EtheE: “Excuse me – he did much wrong in the movie. No matter how much I try, I can not get the image of his holding Frodo at sword point in the caves out of my mind. That was cruel & un-necessary. He had the hobbits where they could do him no harm, and he still just played around with his sword?

“This scene also, btw, directly contradicts something he says in the book: he does not love the sword because of its sharpness, or the arrow for its swiftness – he uses them because he love that which he defends. How is he defending anything when he plays with the Ring on his sword point with Frodo?”

Brian also saw a cruel streak in the film’s Faramir: “The mood in TTT (the movie) was that Faramir had a cruel streak in him (the strange smile on his face when Gollum was captured was rather unsettling, among other instances), and shared much the same weakness as his brother. This is contrasted by Tolkien’s description of Faramir as the “fair” brother who listened to Gandalf, and showed a hint of the glory of Numenor, not its weakness.”