To all those who’ve sent in Trilogy Tuesday reports, I can only say – I’ve been overwhelemed by the response. There’s a pile more that I still haven’t touched and I don’t know whether I’ll be able to get to. Which is not to say that they’re bad reports, just that I don’t physically have the time to get to them all. Here’s some more including a sad tale from Christchurch in New Zealand.

Ringer Micaela, Wichita, KS

I so enjoyed the costumes the kids wore (see news report below). Me, I wore comfy clothes, carried a pillow, and packed Tums, Tylenol and cough drops, (which rescued our neighboring moviegoer during Two Towers).

This all began for me as a birthday present back in October. My favorite theater in Wichita, the enormously elegant Warren Theatre, was granted the Trilogy Marathon, and I stood in line for an hour to get the perfect seats in the balcony… I bought two, in order to bring my friend Roxy along. The balcony hold the only reserved seats, and they cost twice as much as the main floor at $50. But hey, no line to wait in. I was surprised not to see a line at all when we got there at 11:30 for lunch… can Wichita be that out of it, I wondered? Nah.. they’d all been let in early out of the windy bright Wichita weather.

While there were no concession breaks, the show was well managed. Simple rules were announced: no switching seats, order from the concession stand and feel free to eat in your seats, trash to the end of the rows. Those of us in the balcony were served by waiters during the hour-long intermissions (shows at 1, 5:30 and 10 pm) We started on time for every show. We cheered for every show. Roxy, my friend, had not seen Two Towers extended, so it was a special treat for her. I was glad I had my pillow, as I had to squirm a bit to find a comfortable position, but it was great to see tiny details I have missed over the months of watching Fellowship, shocking to see the Cave Troll and Helm’s Deep up so close, and thrilling to be that close to seeing ROTK. When it started, no more squirming, I was totally involved and only noticed an hour into it that my leg had “gone to sleep”. I did have to ask Roxy if we could hold hands during Shelob.

Our gifts came at the end of the last movie, and I’m so pleased with this, the best remembrance of a special time. Well, this is not a review of the movie, which is so magnificent an achievement…I am thrilled I lived long enough to see it. But as to Trilogy Tuesday, I want them to do it again, with all three movies in Extended mode, and I will be there! (Perhaps next year, when I turn 50, as does Lord of the Rings).

Ringer Susan, Christchurch, NZ

I wish I could say that ALL the theatres in New Zealand (home of Lord Of The Rings, right?!) had done as great a job with Trilogy Tuesday as the those in the US, but I’m afraid I can’t. My partner and I had the misfortune to be attending the event at Hoyts 8 Moorhouse in Christchurch – which in a nutshell, was more than a little disappointing. I should have been suspicious when in the weeks leading up to Dec 17th there was nothing in the local paper about it and no special effort made to promote it through Hoyts website, AND that they were billing it as a “double feature” separate from the midnight ROTK screening. Consequently the 400-seat theatre was only half-full, which seemed such a shame.

During FOTR there were a number of problems with the picture and sound quality – white bars would periodically flash across the screen; the picture suddenly became dimmer for long sections of the movie (as if the brightness of the projector had been reduced?); there were several glitches in the soundtrack (which wasn’t loud enough to drown out the bass rumble from some other movie playing on the screen next door) the worst of which was a 15-20 second silence during Boromir’s death scene!!! I didn’t go out and complain for fear of missing a favourite scene, but did give them some “feedback” in the break before TTT. Things were a little better in the second film, but still the white bars, and the long periods of reduced brightness (in places which are not that dark in the original movie or the DVD) kept jolting us out of the Middle Earth experience and back to “reality”.

So, we got to the second break, glad to have seen those new scenes on the big screen, but missing the feeling of total immersion we’d been anticipating. The lobby was of course jammed with people waiting for ROTK, which was being shown on 4 screens in the Hoyts complex. Many of those who’d just arrived had seats in the theatre where we’d been watching the “double feature”. Because we’d bought our tickets very early we were able to keep the same seats for ROTK, but many of the faces around us had changed and I can only assume many of the people who’d sat through FOTR and TTT with us had to change seats for ROTK – so no great “shared experience” energy among the crowd.

After waiting in a long line for the loos, we got back to our seats at 11:55pm – expecting the movie to start at 12:01am. It got to 12:10am and nothing happening – people were starting to get impatient, but there was no explanation from the theatre. We then sat through at least 20 minutes of trailers, and adverts, some twice! until the movie finally started half an hour late!!! I could possibly just have coped with the poor picture and sound in FOTR and TTT if we’d at least been able to go straight into ROTK, but this long wait and bombardment with advertising bullshit was the worst interruption imaginable to what was supposed to be a continuous movie experience.

I loved ROTK and am off to see it again tomorrow, but am sad that my first viewing of this masterpiece, which was created with so much love and attention to detail, was soured by frustration at the lack of care taken by Hoyts. I feel they really let down not only South Island LOTR fans, but also the filmmakers, and New Line, and Roadshow distributors. Hoyts quite clearly didn’t get the point of “Trilogy Tuesday”, and now I’m kicking myself for not spending the extra money to go to the Embassy in Wellington. The saving grace of this whole journey was the long drive home yesterday (after a few hours sleep). We spent 6-hours on a glorious summer day travelling through the spectacular Southern Alps landscape where the films were shot – plenty of time to savour/discuss the wonderful memories of ROTK. THIS felt really like being immersed in Middle Earth.

Finally, many thanks to PJ and all involved in making these fantastic films, but definitely no credit to Hoyts 8 Moorhouse, for their presentation.

Ringer Doug, Winnipeg, CA

My name is Doug and I attended the Trilogy Tuesday in Winnipeg, Canada at the Famous Players Silver city at Polo park. That’s a very long title eh.

There were four of us who had tickets for this event and were planning to arrive at the theater around am, thinking the doors opened at noon. We had a struggle to get up Tuesday morning and after my friend’s NBA live 2004 game, which took 30 minutes, we then headed over to the theater. We were dressed for the cold as it was about 15 degrees F and were at the theater by am.

As we got closer to the theater we saw that there was only 5 people in line. So I waited in line and my friends ditched me to go and get some coffee at the local shop. When they got back I was excited not to see there coffee they had got me, but I was explaining to them that I was on TV. I also noticed a sign on the door of the theater that the will be letting in movie goers at 1030am. I was excited about this and the ability to get out of the cold. The staff let us in only in groups of 10. I was number ten and looked back at my friends and laughed at them, poking fun at them for being number ten. We were ushered to our theater and given the plaque with 3 stills in it. I have two pictures of Pippin and one picture of the shire.

I waited for three hours in the theater before the fellowship started. I was indeed tired from the previous night and was falling asleep throughout this movie. The best cheers during this movie was when Aragon cut of the Uruk’s head. The credits soon came and people stood and gave a thunderous applause. It was a awesome moment to be in.

The Two Towers was also an amazing movie. One of my friends had never seen The two Towers and I was excited to see his face during the movie. The hilarious moments were when the Gandalf and the Rohan Army were coming down the hill towards the Uruks, the girl next to me almost to off my head with her arm. She was very excited about that part. The second hilarious part was when Gandalf and the top actors of Two Towers were looking towards Mordor and said that Helms deep was the beginning and the biggest war is still to come. When the last line was said a guy in the audience yelled out the war would start in 1 hour, the audience laughed so much to the point where Gollum’s lines were being unheard.

After a match on Game boy Advance, the lights dimmed and we were shown the Return of the King. This was an awesome movie. I do not know how to describe it. I would recommend this movie to everyone and indeed bring tissues if you are a die hard fan, you will need them. The synopsis by the end of the movie was a lot of crying or tears in their eyes and when the lights came up there was such a applause that it gave me Goosebumps. This movie was amazing and I cannot wait to see the EE version. Congrats Peter Jackson and crew, you all did an amazing job. Cannot wait till The Hobbit.

I would also like to say that many of the ringers at the movie mentioned Theonering.net. Your website is cleary huge. Keep up your great work.

Ringer John, New Brunswick, New Jersey

I’ve never been particularly good at fandom. I’m generally too jaded and cynical. So despite my eagerness to see the films all as one block – I was a bit worried about being stuck in the “crazed fan” climate for nearly 12 hours.

All of my fears were waylaid. The vast majority of people were very pleasant and considerate. Most were amazingly down to earth and did not take themselves too seriously, while obviously holding these films in a huge amount of reverence. I did not hear a single cellphone and I can count on one hand the number of people who shuffled in a disturbing manner, or even breathed loudly during the films…particularly RoTK.

The theater – Leows New Brunswick – treated the fans royally. They took it as seriously, yet as good natured, as most of the fans seem to. There was a quality, catered chicken and rib dinner for those who wanted it (high priced, but all you can eat). The concessions were remarkably reasonable for “entertainment venue” food and drink. They were open to people bringing in outside snacks and drinks – and made sure that any special needs were attended to. And of course, we got those nice WETA freebies.

RoTK went on at 10:00 pm. Thankfully, as for as energized as I was, I was a bit wiped out by that time (happens when you get “old”). At first I thought the cheering and clapping at a screen was a bit silly. But by the time Rohan “answered the call”, I couldn’t help but feel the emotion and power myself. Not just of the film, but of the sincere love of the fans for these characters, actors, the story, and…the *being* with others who understand this obsession. I’ve seen the film again with “normal” people in a “normally” crowded theater. Most of the patrons there expressed little difference between the previews for Spider Man 2 and RoTK. They seemed equally (un)excited about both. It was an entirely different experience sharing the moments with sincere fans. In contrast, I will always remember the deft silence, the tense build, and the cheering and thundering clap of the T.T. fans as Sam confronts Shelob, the Rohirrim savage the orcs at Minas Tirith, and the Ring is finally cast into the lake of fire. I haven’t felt that innocent, joyful, and truly awed by film or book in a very long time. Probably not since the first time I read LoTR – many years ago.

Upon leaving I asked my girlfriend what she thought (rhetorically). She replied that she loved it, but was sad it was all over. I agreed. Leaving these characters was much like turning the last page of the novel, Return of the King, for the first time. You feel, even if they are with you forever, their journey is over and you’ll never quite revisit them the same way again. I’ll miss that yearly excitement of the past 3 winters. Waiting, watching, wondering and finally getting my hopes mostly fulfilled. I am honored to have been part of this historic screening. The entire cast and crew of the films, not to mention the fans, should all feel themselves graced for having been part of an experience which can touch so many people. ven jaded cynics like myself. I’m moved very little these days, it says quite a bit about all involved that I feel so inwardly touched by these experiences.

Ringer Nuprin, St Louis

Okay, well. I am going to give you a brief account of the PEOPLE at my Trilogy Tuesday, rather than my reaction to the films themselves. No words can describe how wonderful I felt seeing all three movies together. Take total Tolkien fandom bliss and multiply it by infinity, and it will be a fraction of my enjoyment. But again, I wanted to tell you of the folks around me.

When I arrived early in the morning of Tuesday, I saw that there was a group of about 2 dozen people standing outside the theater that had been there since 9pm the night before. I felt a pang of regret that I did not join these wonderfully jolly folks. I approached them and at first (because it was God-awful windy and cold), we only just huddled around a small grill that was lit with some charcoal for warmth. I caught word of someone going out to get donuts for everyone. This was my first glimpse at how wonderful and kind hearted these folks were.

Then, a fellow who shared my first name approached me and asked “did you sign the seating chart?” Hmmm, well, I hadn’t heard of any. Basically, what happened is that someone had put together an exact diagram of the seats of the theater we were going to be in. It was drawn on a huge board of graph paper. People that were showing up were given the chance to sign this seating chart to secure a seat. And when I asked how this was going to be enforced, someone answered “with common decency”. I thought the idea not only brilliant, but also very kind hearted that someone would take the time to organize this chart to give people that showed up early and chance to secure a good spot. That also gave me and my wife (who had just gotten over the flu) a chance to wait for the rest of the morning in our car with the heat on. God bless these folks!!!

However, when we got into the theater, only about half the people got their seats. The management of the theater so very very pissed off that someone had the decency to organize this, undermining their authority about a “first come, first serve” seating chance. Well, the organizers of the chart were told to stop “telling people where to sit” and to give up the chart, less they be thrown out. Further investigation on my part found out that a couple of guys who had just shown up went straight to 2 seats that was empty (and it was very good seats, right in the middle). These seats were being tentatively held for folks who had camped out the night before, signed the seating chart, and just had not gotten tot he theater so that they could claim these seats. When the chart was brought up to the guys stealing those seats, they brought it up with the management, and management basically told them to hang it up.

I’m not sure how things panned out for everyone, but there was a bit of tension there. By that time, I had already gotten my seat and was taking care of my wife, making sure she had enough water, was comfortable, took her medicine, etc. So, that’s how my Trilogy Tuesday started. I was very unhappy to see the efforts of fans that camped out the night before wasted on such lack of understanding and the failure to just “do the decent thing” and honor the chart. The theater management getting involved to try and “save face” made it even worse (shame on you Wehrenberg…shame on you). But when the movies started, I just got lost and didn’t even think about it until I got back onto TORN. I had to share that story to thank the folks that organized that chart for giving me and my wife (along with almost 2/3 of the rest of the theater) and chance at seeing these movies with the best seats possible. What a noble effort!

Ringer Chris, Hollywood, CA

Howdy, I love your site and I was compelled to write in a report on the Hollywood California screening since I hadn’t seen one yet.

I went by myself, with a single ticket I had won on e-bay for a meager $96.50. I say meager because groups of tickets had been going for upwards of $200-$400 apiece. And yes, it is true that one particular set of juicy seats were bought for over a grand each. Yoiks.

My friends and I all had tickets for ROTK on 12/17, but I had always secretly harbored a desire to go to Trilogy Tuesday. I had been bitterly dissapointed when the event sold out in 15 minutes, and I thought I would never get the chance to attend the grand event. Also, my friends and my wife turn into whiners when confronted with the prospect of staring at a screen for 12 hours.

Anyhoow, I met the ticket seller at the theater ahead of time, he was a nice gent who had an extra ticket to unload, and I was more than happy to oblige. I didn’t have to wait in line for my seat, because dear friends, the Arclight theater in Hollywood is assigned seating only.

A quick aside; I love the Arclight theater. Tickets for regular movies are more expensive than normal theaters – $11 for off peak hours and $14 for prime time; but in exchange you get –

1.) The L.A. Times rated #1 picture and sound quality in Los Angeles.
2.) Assigned seats, which are a dream for big movie events.
3.) A no kid under 4 policy for PG-13 and R rated movies. Awesome.
4.) A no commercial policy, period. Remember when movie theaters showed only trailers?
5.) A no admittance policy 5 minutes after the movie starts. (They waved this one for Trilogy Tuesday, understandably, but for regular movies this policy rocks.)

The Arclight has a dozen top notch theaters, but Trilogy Tuesday was to take place only in the adjacent historic and recently renovated Cineramadome. An 800 seat theater that was one of the first of its kind, a geodesic dome curved screen type thang. Great sound and picture, though the curviture distortion at the edges of the screen isn’t my favorite thing in the world.

So, the event. I picked up my laminated pass with lanyard and proceeded to my seat. On the way there were display cases of sideshow Weta Collectables, it looked like all of them actually. Very cool. There were also life sized statues of Lurtz and a Ring Wraith. Nice.

I sat in my seat for awhile, the theater still mostly empty, and savored the moment. The King of the Golden Hall played quietly, this was going to be cool.

I got back up and went back to the lobby, it was getting crowded, with a fair amount of people in costume. As many people in costume as there were, there were an equal amount of television cameras. All the media had descended and they were interviewing anyone who looked remotely hobbitish. At anyone time there must have been half a dozen reporters and camera operators, the bright lights blaring. This was Hollywood alright, and the media was going to portray it as if everyone in attendance, all 800 of us, were dressed to the Tolkien nines. In reality there might have been 2 dozen people in costume, tops.

But, as much as us cynics tend to snicker, I deep down have always envied the spirit of those compelled to literally dress the part, and I truly believe they bring up the energy level and emotional resonance to big movie events. What can I say, I’m a softie; I do get choked up when an eight-year old dresses like a hobbit.

Speaking of kids, THAT kid, some would say that obnoxious kid, from the Jimmy Kimmel show, was there. He was dressed as a hobbit and hamming it up for the camera. Good for him.

Finally, after getting the obligatory bladder buster LOTR souvenir cup, I headed back to my seat. The energy was high for an Arclight crowd, which I will say is usually very subdued. As much as I love the Arclight, you tend to get more old 35 year old fogeys like me. The energy doesn’t typically hold a candle to the Chinese or the Village in Westwood. But today/tonight it seemed the gang was up for it. My seatmates all introduced themselves, all very friendly, and very young.

An Arclight staffer got on the mike and thanked us all for being there, and to his credit he didn’t dawdle. He explained how it was going to work, with the breaks between movies, the parking validation and assorted details. He also mentioned we would be getting a gift at the end. Cool.

The credits rolled, and we cheered. Once again I was in middle earth, surrounded by friendly people that I didn’t know, but shared a kindred spirit with. I was stoked.

The movie was a blast especially because it was the EE on the big screen. I think we all know what the definitive versions of these movies are Mr. Jackson, wink wink.

My butt numb and my neck sore I took a short walk in between films one and two. The Arclight had a nifty food court set up for the big night with a hot dog stand and box lunches available in the adjacent cafeteria. The whole atmosphere in that area, the box office lobby and courtyard, always feels like a hip scene, and this day, now night, was no different. More costumed people, gearing up for the midnight premieres, I saw a young woman in a white robe. Gandalf? Nope, she had Saruman’s staff. Very cool. Didn’t see any swords and such, the Arclight had made announcements and had signs pleading with people to leave such things at home.

Back in my seat and ready for Two Towers. Another staffer got on the mike and announced we had a special guest to introduce the next movie. My heart jumped. Sean Astin? He lives here you know. Nope. It was THAT kid. Some, and now I, would say that obnoxious kid from Jimmy Kimmel live. Oy. He got up there and yammered a bit with some jokes that fell flat and then tried to get us to chant “Lord of the Rings” after he chanted “Lord”. We all chanted “Start the movie!” instead.

And so the movie rolled. While I think Fellowship benefits from the extra stuff in the EE, I think Two Towers is made a wholly better movie. Great stuff with the brothers and Denethor, fantastic floatsam and jetsam scene. Again, the crowd got into it, especially as the movie approached its climax. You could feel the energy rising, and as Gandalf led the Rohirrim down the hill we all cheered like the spaz geeks we are. We were excited because the scene kicks butt yes, but we were also pumped because we knew that the King was soon to return.

After Towers finished, I returned to the lobby to check out the scene. It was more chaotic than ever, just as many news crews, the Kimmel kid was back at it; and I would swear the people in costume were multiplying. The energy in the room was thick.

Back in my seat, Gawd was I tired; but oh so tingly in anticipation. An announcement was made that we had another special guest to introduce the movie. Oh great. Someone in the crowd groaned. “It’s okay” the Arclight staffer said “It’s someone good this time.”
Up to the mike stepped Sala Baker. Very cool, Sauron, Lurtz and the Witch King stood before us. He was a very sweet man who spoke briefly but from his heart. Rock on dude.

When the LOTR title card came up the biggest cheer of the night erupted. I felt it in my chest.
Personally, big surprise, I think the movie is a master piece. And strangely, I was especially gratified to see it with 800 other people with whom I will probably never see again. We all came with common purpose and spirit, and for those 11 plus hours we WERE a fellowship. A unique experience in my life to be sure. And yes, a spiritually gratifying one. You would never believe, if you saw me on Tuesday, wandering around like a kid on Christmas morning … I’m a pretty cynical no-nonsense dude who rolls his eyes at new age mumbo jumbo crap. But as I blubbered like a baby at those final scenes in ROTK, I was for that one moment at one and at peace with the universe.

Ahem, mushy moment over. Did I mention we got a nifty gift? As others have described; it was a frame plaque thingy with actual movie cells from each film. I got Gandalf in Moria, zombies in the dead marshes and a bunch of tents in ROTK. Neeto.

Ringer Donna, Oregon Coast

We had to drive 4 hours on Monday night to get up to Portland for Trilogy Tuesday. We wanted to be assured a good spot in line for the movies. We made it to the theater by 8:30pm and the 5 of us pulled out our camping gear and made ourselves at home. We ended up with 22 people ahead of us. A group 20 had been there since Sunday taking turns standing in line. We made friends with a couple of ladies who had to come down from Seattle, Wash to see the Trilogy. They had a hotel room but decided to sleep outdoors instead. We drove up from the southern Oregon Coast.

I was thrilled that the weather was clear no rain. I ended up sleeping in my chair bundled up in a sleeping bag and I would not have missed it for the world. After the Two Towers had come out last year I told my girlfriend wouldn’t it be awesome to see all 3 of the movies back to back on the big screen. We figured it was wishful thinking because it had never been done before with any other movies.

I remember the day I heard it was going to happen. I rushed to my girlfriend and told her about it. I was so excited thankfully my boss is a fan also and I got the time off work. We got another friend to go my daughter and my girlfriends daughter. Our own fellowship. That night I discovered we were very lucky to have gotten tickets because the ticket web site had eventually crashed by the overload of people trying to get tickets. Portland was the only place in Oregon it was showing.

One of the groups who was behind us in line for the ROTK had a really sweet couple getting married in line on Tuesday at 6:00pm. We ended up not being able to see it because they started movie # 2 at about 6:05pm. The people at the theater were wonderful. Allowed us to use their restrooms as long as possible. We got to bring food to eat in at the beginning. We got to go in about 12pm and find seats. There was a Trivia contest inside and a costume contest. Our group had 2 hobbits, 2 elves and 1 Lady from Rohan.

We had fun then at 2:00pm the movies began. I had seen the Fellowship several times when it first came out and I also have the Special Director’s Edition. I bought the Two Towers Special Director’s Edition but we all agreed to wait and see it on the big screen see it and for us it made it much more exciting.

I did rent it in August when it first came out. We had nice little breaks in between movies a free refill with purchase of a large drink which was a nice treat. I would say about 10 minutes before the Return of the King began you could feel the anticipation in the air everyone was excited. That was also when they announced we would be getting our gifts after the picture was over. I have to say I was a little confused at the start of the movie. But then the time flew by.

We loved the movie and I had completely forgotten I only had a few hours of sleep the night before. I was in awe at what I saw and by the end I was sad that after all this time it was finally done. Great job Peter Jackson it was a masterpiece, better than the first two movies and I loved them both also. I want to say that I would gladly pay money to see all 3 extended versions of the trilogy on the big screen again back to back. Because there is just something about watching them on a hugh screen with great sound that makes them memorable.

Thank you New Line and Peter Jackson for having the guts to try and do something different (having all 3 movies back to back) and making my wish come true. Also for the wonderful job you did at making JRR Tolkien’s wonderful story come to life.

Ringer Brian, Sioux Falls, SD

I attended the Trilogy Tuesday screening in Des Moines, Iowa. I traveled 280 miles from Sioux Falls, SD. I took my six year old son, who had fallen in love with the first two movies. I felt this day would be more than a once-in-a-lifetime event for him, as this will be a fond childhood memory for him for life.

I write this from the perspective of one who has not read the books and do not consider myself a “ringer”. When I saw Fellowship two years ago, I fell in love with the movie, and in a strange way, felt lucky that I had not read the books, as I could enjoy the movies without feeling let down about something being changed or left out. I didn’t even think I would be able to get tickets to the event. The Des Moines theater was one of the few that did not sell out the first day. I purchased my two tickets about 6-7 hours after they went on sale.

On Monday, December 15 bad weather was moving in and we decided to drive to Des Moines and spend the night instead of going Tuesday morning. On Tuesday morning, we had a late breakfast and went to the theater about 11:45 am. Whatever line there was had already let in. They gave us the Trilogy Tuesday all day pass lanyard, which was a nice touch, especially with a 6 year old. They put our ticket stub with the all day pass. The theater was about 1/3 full at that time. We were able to get our seats about 4 rows from the top, a little in from the aisle. The theater was pretty good about saving your own seat, as long as you were in the building. We just left our jackets there and we did not have any problems with that. We then had to pass the next 2 1/2 hours as our screening started at 2:15. The time went by pretty fast.

We greatly enjoyed the EE version of Fellowship. I had not watched it for about 6 months and it was fun to see the EE on the big screen. The movie started right on time and was over at 5:45pm. The credits started about 10 minutes before that, though, and a lot of us were running for the bathroom as soon as the credits started to roll. The theater, The Wynnsong 16, recognized this was a big event, and spent the time and money to get sponsors and presented everyone with a T-shirt that read:

The Lord of the Rings
The Return of the King
I Survived Trilogy Tuesday
12-16-03

The back of the shirts listed the sponsers. A very nice touch and a keepsake for life! Also, between the first two movies, they provided a free sack lunch from a local restaurant. Very good, indeed!

At 6:30, The Two Towers started. Since the EE had only been out for a month, and we only seen it a few times, we were very excited to see it on the big screen. The credits started to roll about 10:05 and movie ended a little before 10:15. We were told that Return of the King would start at 11:00 but they would be doing a giveaway at 10:50. We had to fend for ourselves for food, but there were a few fast food places open. We got back in our seats early and the theater had a costume contest for the few people that dressed up. The winner received 10 free movie passes, another nice touch from the theater.

When Return of the KIng started, there was only one preview (thank goodness!) and right to the movie. The theater manager tried to joke with us and say they were having problems with the movie and it might be a 1/2 hour wait. Nobody thought it was funny and he said he was just kidding and gave the signal to start the movie. We were all very relieved and settled in for 200 minutes of pure satisfaction. I was thoroughly blown away. It completed the trilogy with a huge exclamation point. I agree with Christopher Lee, who said Samwise, the ordinary man, is the hero. Now that I have seen all three movies, I will now settle in and read the books and I am sure I will thoroughly enjoy them. All in all, an incredible experience and one I will treasure for a lifetime.

Ringer Deja, Baltimore MD

The Senator Theater and its owner were an absolutely class act, start to finish. First, Tom (the owner) avoided all the confusion and discrimination in favor of those with T1 internet connections by independently deciding to sell his tickets on Saturday morning. In line. For cash only. His only regret was allowing people to buy up to 10 tickets.

While we were in line, he and his staff collected email addresses. A week before the showing, we received an email (and could find on the Senator’s website) detailed, specific, and correct instructions on when the doors would open, how seating would be arranged, and how people could get back in and out of the theater. And it all happened exactly as he said it would.

As a side note, I wrote him on Sunday night, since my family had to cancel out on the showing, leaving me with three tickets. He responded within 15 minutes, and connected me to Maegwen, who helped me sell two of the three. Congratulations and kudos to both for going the extra mile.

When I arrived to take my place in line, actors from the local Medieval Times theater were working the crowd, passing out stickers and markers for us to put on our seats once we entered the theater. No ticket? No sticker. This precluded the earlybirds from hogging all the best seats.

Upon entering (single file) we received a complimentary lanyard containing our TT pass, a coupon for the giveaway at the end, and several discount coupons from local eateries, which were heavily used in the one-hour break between FoTR and TTT. There were also pizza places within two blocks of the theater, and the concession stand ran full blast. Also, a local fencing school fenced in between the movies, and a humourous clip called “R2- Beneath the Dome” (think VH-1 Behind the Music-type satire) was shown.

I won’t review the movies (since I already did elsewhere), but it was *so* nice to go with like-minded fans to see these films all together. Days later, images and dialog still pop into my head at all hours.

I again really want to compliment Tom and the Senator Theater for an absolutely class act. I can only pray that New Line would consider another TT when the extended version of RoTK comes out.

Ringer Lesley, Montreal

Ever since I heard about Trilogy Tuesday, way back when you first posted speculation about it on TORn, I ve been looking forward to it. I even emailed the theater in my hometown (in Southern California) begging them to participate. Of course, this was before I even knew if I would be home in time to be there, what with starting university in Montréal. And of course, luck would have it that I would have my last final exam at 9am on the 17th of December. However, I knew that I still wanted to attend some sort of midnight showing of ROTK, even if I would become the psychotically crazy person on my floor.

When the first official news came into TORn on where the screenings would be held, I still had to wait, because the dates for Canada hadn t been posted. Then some info started leaking in, and I started to get worried, because there wasn t any information about Montreal. Sure, I would travel farther away for a screening, but only if I didn t have to worry about final exams! Then, the official dates came in for Canada, and I got so excited. The theater in Montreal was only a couple blocks away from my dorm!

So, on Halloween I set my alarm so I could get up and try to get a ticket over the internet. However, the website wasn t showing the Montréal theater, so I started to freak out. I sent an email to the guys in charge of it, and they replied that the website was screwing up, but they were selling them at the theater. So, I ran (well a combination of nervously walking, hopping, and skipping) to the theater and bought my ticket. I think on my way back, I must have had the goofiest smile on my face. Unfortunately, the tickets sold out soon after, and my friend wasn t able to get one, but I was still very excited to participate in this amazing event.

So, December 15th came around. I knew I had to study, because I wouldn t be able to the next day, but I couldn t get anything done. My friends thought it was very funny watching me, because I was so nervous whenever I was talking to them I would start picking up things and moving them, and then moving them back. I had originally planned on leaving at 7am to wait in line, but they talked some sense into me, how would I survive standing in line outside for several hours with my LA blood? So, I called the theater, and they said they wouldn t be opening the doors until 12, however the manager hinted to me that people could still get in line to wait earlier.

Finally, the day I had been looking forward to for about 6 months came. I ended up getting to the theater at 9:30, and I couldn t see anyone waiting outside, so I was going to wait across the street at a coffee shop til I saw people waiting. IR17;m very glad I didnR17;t, because I realized the movie theater is connected to one of the underground malls, and people had already been waiting by the entrance and were starting to go down the stairs. I ended up the second from the top of the stairs, about the 20th person in line.

However, I almost made a horrible mistake. I got up at 10:10 to walk around the mall and try to find a magazine to read, why study! I ended up, without my magazine, back in line at 10:25. Roughly 5 minutes later, suddenly one of the doors opened, and we realized they were letting us in early. Had I tried harder to find a magazine, I would have returned to find my stuff sitting on a step, alone and me being the first person in line outside the theater, while a lot of people were already waiting right outside the room it was being shown in. However, I was upset at the fans waiting in line at this point. If anybody has been to this theater, they know that the theater we were in was on the third floor, following humongous amounts of escalators and stairs next to them.

I decided to follow whoever was in front of me in line to see it they took the stairs or escalators. He took the stairs for the first mini-flight, and I kept going on the stairs, when he transferred to the escalators. Because I was carrying a rather large bag with heavy books in it, I dragged behind trying to climb the large staircase, and I lost my place in line, even when I took the escalator between the second and third floors. I was rather upset that the fans did not calmly walk up the escalators/stairs and keep the same line, but I guess everything went ok, because I still ended up with my favorite seat.

When everyone who had been waiting in line got into the theater, the theater worker closed and locked the doors, without leaving any indication that people were already lined up inside. I know several people who had been waiting were then separated from their friends who were coming later, but everyone caught up eventually. So, I was able to get some studying done in the hour and a half before they opened up the actual doors for us to sit down in. And as they began to let us into the room, we looked at the escalators, and noticed a lot of confused people coming up to wait in line behind us, realizing they weren t first, they were actually pretty far back in line. I felt sorry for them at first, then I recognized the fact, that I had been waiting in line longer than they had, and they were still at the same place that they would ve been had the doors never been unlocked or they had been always unlocked.

So, as we were filling into the theater, we were wondering what was taking so long, then I saw the boxes with WETA on them, and I suddenly got really excited. Yeah, we got free stuff! (Yes, I understand the price was probably just added onto the ticket price, but still, it s exciting getting unexpected presents.) I ran up the rows in the theater, and got a place smack dab in the middle of the theater, about 3 or 4 rows from the top. I probably would ve had the perfect seat one row down, but I was still exceptionally satisfied. Once I got into the theater, I gave up studying all together, I wouldn t want to bump the people next to me with the awful physics book, would I? I got my ROTK popcorn tub, put all my stuff in order, figured out what was in my film frame (Isildor cutting Sauron s finger, Sam sleeping in the Dead Marshes, and a shot of Sam in Frodo and Sam s first argument in ROTK), memorized the commercials they show us while waiting for movies to begin, and then got ready for the long haul.

The manager guys got up and talked to us, first in French (which I didn t understand, but could tell the guy got the crowd more pumped up) and then in English, telling us to not put our feet on the back of the seat in front of us, turn of cell phones, emergency exits, etc. Then the previews started. It was all hush for the preview for ROTK, then someone shouted, That s what I m talking about and that got a combination of laughs and cheers. Then the movie started. It is so amazing to watch the extended version on the big screen. It was just fun, to be with all these other people watching a movie we ve all been looking forward to this movie, and are truly into it, not having to worry about snickers from an ungrateful watcher.

After FOTR ended, many people went out of the theater, just to stretch, grab some food, etc. The theater didn t provide anything, but they also didn t mention anything about not bringing in outside food, so I did what a broke college kid does, eat the pathetic sandwich I brought from the caf. I also got to meet the people around me and had a nice conversation with one of the guys on my right about how much of a difference it is seeing the extended version in a theater rather than back home on a laptop or tv with only a few friends around. So, the 40 minutes seemed to take forever to pass, and then TTT started. IR17;d been limiting my watching of the extended versions of both movies, because I didn t want it to be a bore during the theater showing, so it was exciting because it was only the second time I saw it all the way through. The only complaint I had was that they showed the exact same previews in front of TTT as they did for FOTR, including the preview for ROTK; I actually started to take bets with the guy next to me if they would show the preview in front of the actual movie.

But after TTT, I got out of the theater to stretch and walked down throughout the theater. I discovered several encampments of people waiting for midnight showings. One of the theater workers said they were showing 4, and maybe a 5th, because of the demand. Anyways, I then went back and sat down for ROTK! I lost my bet, they only showed 2 previews in front of the movie, neither was ROTK, but I think I m going to scream if I have to watch the preview for The Butterfly Effect again. Don t get me wrong, it seems like an interesting movie, but seeing the preview several times in only a few hours was getting on my nerve.

So then, ROTK!!! The only problem I had with it was that it seemed too rushed. There wasn t a lot of breathing time in between scenes, and I didn’t really like that. Like in the scene with the Witch King and Dernhelm, I don t think it got the applause it should have, because we weren’t given the opportunity to do so; it immediately went to Legolas s awesome scene. However, I had chills during the entire thing, and really, really, really look forward to the extended version! I do have to give props to the credit makers-I thought they were beautifully done, and the perfect end to these amazing movies

So afterwards I went back to my dorm (it was very weird walking through the icy streets of downtown Montréal clutching a ROTK popcorn bucket, but even weirder was how a lot of people left theirs in the theater), showed off my film frames to my friend who had spent the whole time studying that I had spent watching the movies. As for the final 7 hours later, I d rather not talk about it. I m sure though I got high enough on it to pass the class, which is all that I was going for.

Ringer Shalane, Hawaii

Here’s what happened in Hawaii for Trilogy Tuesday:

The schedule was the doors to the theater would open at 8 AM. Everyone would be ushered into a theater according to date of ticket purchase to wait. Then they would be ushered into THE theater which would be used for the showing of the three films, where they would choose their seat. They then would be given a tag with their seat number on it which would be their seat for the duration of the Trilogy, and then they could leave until show time, which for FOTR was scheduled for 2 PM.

So we got to the theater at 6 AM and fortunately were the first in line. Only minutes thereafter, people started arriving to line up. By 7 AM we were four across and the line wrapped all the way around the long wall of the theater complex, doubling back on itself. The theater management had set up four roped-off isles with signs designating date of purchase, but we were not to actually get into these until a bit later. Meanwhile, we waited. The vast majority of the crowd was cheerful and well behaved; however there were a couple of people who came late, saw the long line, and attempted to cut in line in their own sly manner, much to the jeers and shouts of most everyone else who had been waiting for hours. At around 7:45 we were told to get into our respective lines by date of purchase.

At 8 AM promptly we were taking into the theater, and after that things flowed so incredibly smoothly it was amazing. So many thanks are due to Pono Shim, of the Concierge Services at Ward theaters, for arranging things for the benefit of the majority and for the coordination of all this madness. After we got our seat, we got our sticker put on our tags for our Hobbit meal that was to be served between FOTR and TTT: blue for the “Rabbit Stew” and green for the “Vegetarian Stew”. It was great, since we could now come and go at will. There was very nice LOTR merchandise available to all of us at a nice discount as well in the lobby. Our Trilogy Tuesday T-shirts were wonderful also, with the words: “Trilogy Tuesday, The Real Marathon, December 16, 2003, Honolulu Hawaii” on the left sleeve. (The Honolulu Marathon had just been run the Sunday before)

Before the beginning of the first film, Pono Shim spoke, and a member of Tol Andúnë, the Hawaii Chapter of the Tolkien Society, spoke about her recent trip to New Zealand to tour the movie sites. Then it began! We were in Middle-earth heaven! Also, before the start of the ROTK, Tol Andúnë passed out little boxes of kleenex to everyone in anticipation of the emotions which they knew would run high!They acknowledged Mr. Shim with a gift for his hard work to make this event a memorable one. The film strips presented to everyone at the end of ROTK was the crowining glory! We were so surprised and grateful for this wonderful treasure. Truly, this was a day and night to remember!

DISCLAIMER I can’t speak for the credibility of this story or what is going on with this situation… but here is the word on the wire:

I have it on good authority that UGC have received an email from Entertainment, the distribution company for Return Of The King. It is to inform that the sound problems that many have experienced on their viewing of the film.

An underwater musical experience is how I would describe it. It is apparently a problem with the master copy for the UK, but there is no mention that there are any attempts being made to rectify the issue.

Personally, I think this is disgaceful for such a big release to be suffering these problems and think it should be investigated.

Call me Frankie From Empire Online.

Update: I live in the UK, and although I saw it at an Odeon cinema, and also at a Showcase cinema, the sound was more than satisfactory– Ringer NR

Cameos, cameos everywhere … Here’s just a few of the cameos from Return of the King – there’s probably lots more as well.

  • Sean Astin’s daughter plays Elanor, daughter of Sam and Rosie.
  • Sarah McLeod’s daughter plays Frodo, son of Sam and rosie.
  • Peter Jackson’s children have cameos as Gondorian children.
  • Peter Jackson is the captain of the Corsairs of Umbar. He also had a longer ‘cameo’ of around two minutes where he battles a major character – reportedly Legolas – but decided to cut it from the theatrical release. He spoke about this at the world premiere press conference in Wellington.
  • TORn Staffer Quickbeam has a few seconds of fame as a Gondorian soldier.
  • Previsualisation supervisor Christian Rivers as the Gondorian soldier in charge of the beacon.
  • Senior prosthetics supervisor Gino Acevedo is a Corsair of Umbar.
  • Richard Taylor is a Corsair of Umbar.
  • Bret McKenzie makes a reappearance as Figwit (one of Arwen’s escorts) and even gets to speak some lines!
  • John Howe appears as a Gondorian soldier.
  • Royn Tolkien plays a Gondorian ranger preparing the defences of the ruined city of Osgiliath, braced for an assault by the evil lord Sauron’s armies of orcs. Read more on BBC Online

Years of waiting are finally over; Peter Jacksons ‘The Return Of The King’ has hit cinemas all over the world. This weekend in #thehalloffire we will go through ‘the Return of the King’ scene for scene and marvel at the epic conclusion of this fantastic movie trilogy. So if you haven’t seen the movie yet; run to your nearest theater now so that you can join us in marvelling at the charge of the Rohirrim, the battle of the Pelennor Fields, the Paths of the Dead and all your other favorite moments.

Upcoming topics:

weekend 271203-281203
The Return of the King; topic to be chosen after first movie HoF

weekend 030104-040104
The Return of the King; topic to be chosen after first movie HoF

weekend 100104-110104
Peter Jacksons ‘The Lord of the Rings’; the trilogy as a whole

Times:
Saturday Chat:
5:30pm ET (17:30)
[also 11:30pm (23:30) CET and 9:30am Sunday (09:30) AET]

Sunday Chat:
7:00 pm (19:00) CET
[also 1:00pm (13:00) ET and 5:00am (05:00) Monday morning AET]

ET = Eastern Time, USA’s East Coast
CET = Central European Time, Central Europe
AET = Australian East Coast

Do you have a possible topic for Hall of Fire? Drop us a line at
halloffire@theonering.net

Beverly Hills, CA – The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences today announced the seven films being considered for Achievement in Visual Effects for the 76th Academy Awards®.

The films in consideration are listed below in alphabetical order:
“The Hulk”
“The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King”
“Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World”
“Peter Pan”
“Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl”
“Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines”
“X2”

Fifteen-minute clip reels from each of the seven films will be screened for the Visual Effects Award Nominating Committee on January 21. The members will then nominate three of these seven films for Oscar consideration.

The finalists will be announced along with nominations in 23 other categories on Tuesday, January 27, at 5:30 a.m. PST.

Academy Awards for outstanding film achievements of 2003 will be presented on Sunday, February 29, 2004, at the Kodak Theatre at Hollywood & Highland® and televised live by the ABC Television Network at 5 p.m. PST, beginning with a half-hour arrival segment.

Joel writes:

I was Zeosoez in this chat (you’ll see my comment at the end), but I’d prefer to go by Firestar on your site, if that’s okay. Here’s the transcript:

DishDiva says: Welcome to MSN Live! This afternoon we are pleased to welcome actor Sean Astin back to MSN!

DishDiva says: Sean stars in the Lord of the Rings trilogy!

DishDiva says: Sean, it’s great to have you back! How are you doing today? You have fans here from around the world! Thanks for being here!

Sean_Astin_live says: Last night I made a spontaneous appearance to a Manhattan theatre last night at 12:01.

DishDiva says: I imagine this must be an insane day for you.

Sean_Astin_live says: Today has been a bit more sedate because I did a interview with Rolling Stones and then I had a few hours of radio station interviews. So the rest of the day I got to veg-out and it’s been a lot more relaxing than yesterday or the day before.

DishDiva says: There are so many fans online who are so passionate about Lord of the Rings, does this surprise you?

DishDiva says: I mean there are people who know how to speak Elvish!

Sean_Astin_live says: A couple in Portland got married in line, that ran on the news today, and I found that extrordinary. I’ve been exposed to some of this intense apprecation about the films but it keeps getting more, more extreme. The last 36 hours and the next couple of

Sean_Astin_live says: days will be the pinnacle. It’s been unexpected. It’s been an “Unexpected party.”

HobbitFan2009 in Onstage_1 asks: Yay! I’m really happy! My dad is taking me to see ROTK tonight!!!!! What was your favorite scene to film?

Sean_Astin_live says: I loved finally getting to fight Shelob. I hope you have a great time at the movie.

DishDiva says: That is one scary spider.

Iluvlegolas3 in Onstage_1 asks: this is so cool talk to me

Panamapk in Onstage_1 asks: Thank you so much for being here! We are all crazy fans, don’t get too scared!

PatriciaF82 in Onstage_1 asks: Hi Sean. Did anyone play practical jokes on the movie set?

Sean_Astin_live says: But of course. The most recent practicle joke was in Berlin and Elijah was in New York doing Saturday Night Live doing satalite during the night and he couldn’t see anyone. Dom possed as Gunther and he asked some rude questions. Elijah was mortified

Sean_Astin_live says: trying not to get worked up at the questions given him by this fake journalist.

greatescape86 in Onstage_1 asks: I am impressed with your short film “The Long and Short of It.” Any upcoming projects you are directing?

Sean_Astin_live says: Thank you for the compliment. It is really fun that so many people have seen it on the DVD. I have decided to make myself wide open in terms of my availability and to focus on one project to see what opportunities present themselves with “Return of the

Sean_Astin_live says: King.” My publicist said to me that he hopes that I will hopefully be in front or behind the camera very soon.

Mr-Nonickname in Onstage_1 asks: Hey Sean! I heard that your daughter played Elanor in Returrn of the King. Is this True? If it is, did she like acting?

Sean_Astin_live says: Right now I’m relaxing at E News Daily, just kicking back.

Sean_Astin_live says: It is true, she liked being part of the film but I don’t know that she likes acting. She does like having her picture taken and has a lot of personality in front of the camera so we need to keep an eye on her.

Palandin1 in Onstage_1 asks: Sam is my favorite character in the books. You have done such an awesome job portraying Sam. What are your favorite attributes of his character?

Sean_Astin_live says: It was a several year project to get her to look like me. I had help from my beautiful bride. (laughs)

Sean_Astin_live says: In one of the reviews I read about the performance the journalist said he thought I captured the quiet strength of the character and I’ve thought about that idea and enjoyed it. I can rattle of a string of adjectives for that character but I’ve thought

Sean_Astin_live says: about the character so much that those word change over time. So right now I like quiet strength.

TheDeadParrot3 in Onstage_1 asks: What’s the weirdest piece of merchandise you’ve seen your face on?

Sean_Astin_live says: I can’t talk about the airplane, stamps or currency in New Zealand because they weren’t murchandise. We are actual legal tender there, I feel like Gulliver. There are some weird puzzles, are we toilet paper yet? (laughs)

Sean_Astin_live says: My wife just looked at me and said “Bobblehead!”

djdeathskiss in Onstage_1 asks: Hey Sean- You rocked in ROTK! Were you as emotional as the rest of us when you finally saw the finished film?

Sean_Astin_live says: When I first saw it in it’s unfinished form in England I cried harder than I’ve ever cried in my life. When I saw the final version I was mostly analytical and dispassionate figuring what had been cut out. I’m hoping in the extended version of the DVD

Sean_Astin_live says: that I can reach the same level of emotional attachment. There was so much that had to be cut out and that impacted how I responded to the film. I’m glad that everyone doesn’t know what’s cut out so they can have their own opinion of the film. The last 45

Sean_Astin_live says: minutes of the film is very satisfying for me to watch.

DishDiva says: It really is about you and Elijah’s character.

Sean_Astin_live says: There’s such intimacy in the characterization and so much weight given to it that we ultimately bare, the acute focal point in the film. But if everyone wasn’t playing their part and the music coming together so well people wouldn’t have that emotional

Sean_Astin_live says: experience.

Ringbearer1127 in Onstage_1 asks: Hey Sean, me and my friends just saw the Return of the King last night. It was awesome! We gave it a standing ovation. If there’s anything you’d like to say to the fans, what would it be?

Sean_Astin_live says: Quite simply thank you. The thought that people like you are giving standing ovations in cimemas where you think we can’t hear or feel your energy, fills me with gratitude and we feel it around the world.

Sean_Astin_live says: We just ignore the boos and hecklers. (laughs)

hello_huge_fan_101 in Onstage_1 asks: What is your favorite thing about Tolkiens books?

Sean_Astin_live says: I think my favorite thing would have to be how many different, incredible observations of human nature he interweaves into this story. You can read it and learn about yourself, communicated so clearly and articulately. Tolkien must have been a good study

Sean_Astin_live says: of human behavior and he fused that and enlightenment into his work. That’s what I like about it.

PleasantPineapple in Onstage_1 asks: Hi Sean, I’ve heard the final film has created some Oscar buzz. Do you and the other cast members plan on attending? As a CA. Native I’m excited to see how it plays out.

Sean_Astin_live says: I’m excited too. I’m nervous. I don’t know that anyone would have plans. I know Peter Jackson would fly from New Zealand. We’re all on the edge of our seats for that. I would be lying if I said it wasn’t a consideration for us. Knowing that this last

Sean_Astin_live says: episode has been given to the world now, everyone takes great pride and satisfaction that the fans have enjoyed the films. Hopefully our peers will include this movie in their thoughts when the time comes.

Sean_Astin_live says: Peter thinks that people should vote from their heart and let the chips fall where they may.

AnamSamWise in Onstage_1 asks: Hi Sean. Our family thinks you’re the best! We love ya! Funny question for you – what did you and the rest of the fellowship do when in an interview you guys found that “Frodo” exposed the secret tattoo?

Sean_Astin_live says: Tell your family I said thank you very much. This story has gotten a lot of press in the last few days. Ian was the first to show his tatoo and then I was next to show it on TV on accident. The Elijah felt like everyone was showing their and he showed his

Sean_Astin_live says: We’re all very forgiving of each other with the pact we tried to keep.

WantsOlderWomen in Onstage_1 asks: What was the last scene you shot, and was it really emotional knowing that you have spent the last 2 years with these people and now its over?

Sean_Astin_live says: WantsOlderWoman, hope she’s out there. (laughs)

Sean_Astin_live says: The last scene that made it in the final cut Frodo and Sam on the plains as the Eye is bearing down on them. I was exhausted and it was emotional and I didn’t experience the full emotionality of the experience until I saw the cut in England.

Sean_Astin_live says: I did cry that night because Peter gave a speach and showed out takes and gave me, my wife and daughter presents including feet, the dress my daughter wore, and an Elvin broach. We did know we had to do press for the film so we knew we’d see the other

Sean_Astin_live says: actors.

©øłøѓãđø_68 in Onstage_1 asks: Wasn’t it hard to act with the character Gollum?

Sean_Astin_live says: No, it was not hard in the sense that people might think that working with a “CG” character. Andy Serkis made it so much easier with his sheer force of his intensity of a dramatic actor. There are more fight scenes and a lot more emotionality and those

Sean_Astin_live says: take a physical tole on you. It was difficult lagistically to work with the computer things, but working with Gollum wasn’t hard, it was new and innovated but not hard.

Biggertaylorboydstaff in Onstage_1 asks: What do you think about all the quips people make about the hobbit’s sexualities?

Sean_Astin_live says: I think it’s funny. I enjoy actually seeing other people get off on exploring their own ideas of their own sexuality through these characters. I don’t think that those discussions come organically out of the material. I think the material lacks the

Sean_Astin_live says: sexuality people focus on but I don’t begrudge people to think about what they feel as long as they are not hurting anybody.

Reesh2009 in Onstage_1 asks: What did your kids think about seeing you on the big screen as a hobbit?

Sean_Astin_live says: I don’t think the baby gets it. She did when I was on TRL yesterday, she walked up to the TV and said “Dad, dad” and wanted me to pick her up. Alexandra was uncomfortable with the dirty feet idea but playing a hobbit herself she gets it. At the end of the

Sean_Astin_live says: day when they took off my feet she would pick off the glue that was left behind. I hope she doesn’t develop a fetish.

Sean_Astin_live says: I’m looking out over time square and there’s a huge Reuetr’s newsboard and I just saw myself and Elijah scrolling down it.

HannColl in Onstage_1 asks: Did you enjoy getting the chance to do comedy in Fifty First Dates? How was Adam Sandler to work with?

Sean_Astin_live says: I relish the opportunity to do something so completely different from Sam. I think I’ve got real comedy chops in me and I was able to show a glimmer of them in the part. Adam Sandler is something to behold. He carries himself with grace and I enjoyed

Sean_Astin_live says: being in his realm.

Zachgo51 in Onstage_1 asks: I was just wondering is their any chance that their will be movies for books like The Hobbit, or Books that have to do with Lord of the Rings

Sean_Astin_live says: Sam isn’t in the Hobbit but someone brought up that I might be able to paly Gaffer Gamgee in makeup. It would be fun if they figure out the rights issue and if Peter commits to do it.

Palandin1 in Onstage_1 asks: On the scenes where you are punching out Gollum (GO SAM!), were you punching Andy Serkis or thin air?

Sean_Astin_live says: Punching Gollum, I never punched Andy, I only got to punch thin air or sand bags.

gabrielrose-livejournal in Onstage_1 asks: Out of all the movies you have worked on, which one is your favorite?

Sean_Astin_live says: Hard to say, I would probably say “Lord of the Rings” or “Rudy” or “Goonies” I had fun working on a film called “Kimberly.” Not many people saw it but I was in good shape and was at a good time in Philly and Ally was young it was a great time.

Sean_Astin_live says: I’m sort of overwhelmed by the volume of how many people are into these movies. It’s great to get off planes and see screaming people but it seems like a more direct communication with fans of the film when I can do chat shows like that and hear such

Sean_Astin_live says: great and interesting questions. Reporters and journalists can be hard, but people like you are pure. The fans rock. Asking the quesitons that have to be asked let the actors communicate their ideas and shape the response of people. But I’m not like that

Sean_Astin_live says: I am more trusting of the audience and what I like about the fan questions is that they are unusually specific and you get the sense of personalities with everyone’s handles, names.

curious_mandy_gamgee in Onstage_1 asks: So you act. You direct. You write. You’ve done some politics. What’s next, Mr. Multitasker?

Sean_Astin_live says: (laughs) Grad school? (laughs) You forgot fatherhood. (laughs)

Sean_Astin_live says: I’ll tell you what, relaxation, I’m looking forward to studying the fine art of relaxation.

DishDiva says: You deserve it at this point.

Sean_Astin_live says: The only fear is that I’ll relax and am ready to get back to work I’ll have missed the boat. I don’t know if it’s necessary to worry about that so I’ll keep slogging on and see what happens.

DishDiva says: Well, Sean, from all of your fans from around the world, best of luck with “Return of the King” and “Fifty First Dates.”

Sean_Astin_live says: My heart is filled with love and gratitiude for all the fans and the incredible response they’ve given me and ways they’ve shown me. It’s very meaningful to me and I say thank you.

Sean_Astin_live says: I love the technology age where I can communicate with everyone around the world.

Laubr5151 in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks for everything Sean – I truly look forward to seeing you in future films – you are SO talented!

DishDiva says: Do you have a COMMENT you would like to get onstage? Click the submit question button and enter it now!!

DishDiva says: We’ll try to get as many as can up onstage!!

Mr-Nonickname in Onstage_1 asks: We love the technology where we can talk to our favorite actors!

Tsuta1 in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks a whole lot for coming to talk to all of us! It’s been a real pleasure. Good luck in the future.

southernbelle_23 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, I love you in all you do. You are a wonderful actor.

åñgë£îç_§ûï©’ðê in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, you’ve come a long way in the entertainment business and I really hope to see you around for a long time in the future. Good luck!

mermaid4488 in Onstage_1 asks: Thank you so much Sean, I have been a fan since Goonies! You are amazing and keep up the awesome work!

Togart_Green in Onstage_1 asks: I loved the movies. Thanks for making a dream come true

SymposiacFabi in Onstage_1 asks: I love you Sean!! keep up the good work!

PatriciaF82 in Onstage_1 asks: Thank you for letting Sean answer my question.

ElberethElendil2 in Onstage_1 asks: I can’t believe I’m actually here! It has been AMAZING to see you! Thanx for coming!

theclassicrockjunkie in Onstage_1 asks: I am a huge fan Mr. Astin. Best wishes and God Bless. I hope to meet you in person some day!!!!!!!!!

¿TJ¿1 in Onstage_1 asks: Looking forward to seeing you in other movies

curious_mandy_gamgee in Onstage_1 asks: You are an inspiration to many people, Sean, especially me up here in Canada. Merry Christmas, YOU’RE MY HERO!

Isildae2 in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks Sean!! We all love you!!

goonies_28 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, you’ve been my favourite actor. Thanks so much for everything. I have met you in person and you’re the nicest one ever =)

Endokryne246 in Onstage_1 asks: It’s so great that you appreciate your fans so much. I know I loved the Trilogy!

GildorInglorion1 in Onstage_1 asks: I’m a big fan of you Sean!! Thank you for being here today!

HannColl in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, thank you so much for being Our Sam and for all the joy you’ve given so many.

EJ0238 in Onstage_1 asks: God Bless you, Sean and all involved with this monumental feat.

bloodytears182 in Onstage_1 asks: I LOVE YOU SEAN GOOD LUCK!

MunggyWunggy2 in Onstage_1 asks: you’re very inspiring! you have no idea!

littledawnyk in Onstage_1 asks: you were hands down the BEST actor in the return of the king, sam really kicked butt!!!

WantsOlderWomen in Onstage_1 asks: Fantastico!!!!!! Thanks for the great performance Sean

simplybeingnadine in Onstage_1 asks: Thank you for chatting with us– good luck and god bless. Merry Christmas to you and your family.

Beatlefan412 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean…I have been a major fan for so long. I love you! Thank you for coming!

GooniesGirl8 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean is such a great guy! Very open and honest, just amazing. He deserves every happiness and good thing. Sean rocks! Goonies never say die!!

Dejavu_85 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, congrats on the Lord of the Rings Movies, and thanks for coming and talking to us

Arwen_Undomiel_8708 in Onstage_1 asks: You’re amazing and thank you so much for bringing Sam to life!

Lunahobbit1 in Onstage_1 asks: I’ve gotten into helping the elderly because of your inspirational speech at GenUnited. Thank you Sean, it has blessed me.

Tippman8 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean is truly a wonderful actor a person!!!

mmgosset in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, you an an incredible and gifted actor..I am in awe of your talent keep up the good work!!!1

Samus45 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean, you rock. And Sam rocks. And there is general rocking all around. Yay.

IndigoAphrodisiac in Onstage_1 asks: I hope your future hold more entertainement, and I’m glad you get time to settle down and be a dad now. Parenthood is just as, if not more trying than acting

SpazTheeHalfling in Onstage_1 asks: You, and the rest of the cast are my inspiration. THANK YOU!

Reesh2009 in Onstage_1 asks: I LOVE YOU SOOOO MUCH MAN

Mr-Nonickname in Onstage_1 asks: There couldnt be a better person to be Sam but you Sean!

dripping_with_punk in Onstage_1 asks: You’re so awesome! I wish only the best for you in the future! You’re a good soul and the fans really appreciate it.

SpazTheeHalfling in Onstage_1 asks: You are the one who has inspired me to get into acting, now I’m in ‘The hobbit’ play! THANK YOU SO MUCH! YOU RULE!

ickthus88the2nd in Onstage_1 asks: YOUR AN GREAT ACTOR KEEP IT UP BUT GET SOME REST AND MERRY CHRISTMAS

elfforest902 in Onstage_1 asks: Bye, you’re my favorite character.

WhereTheySellPints in Onstage_1 asks: Incredible. Amazing. Thanks for everything! MERRY CHRISTMAS!

Sarumanly in Onstage_1 asks: Happy holidays, Sean! May the ponies nance!

¤ßаßγĐøłł¤ŦĭиꙤ in Onstage_1 asks: MERRY CHRISTMAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Iluvlegolas3 in Onstage_1 asks: SEAN YOUR REALLY AWESOME AND IM NOT SAYING IT BECAUSE EVERYONE ELSE IS I AM SAYING IT BECAUSE ITS TRUE

theLASTsymphony in Onstage_1 asks: You must honestly be overwhelmed by the number of times you recieve this comment, but you DESERVE every single “I love you, you’re AWESOME!”s that you get. Thanks SO much for coming, keep up the amazing work!

Beatlefan412 in Onstage_1 asks: Thank you for creating such an awesome Samwise. I love you.-Jessica from Evergreen, Colorado

hewene in Onstage_1 asks: You have made movie Sam and book Sam one and the same for me! Your portrayal is amazing!

Mr-Nonickname in Onstage_1 asks: You are one of the purest actors i have ever seen!

DomEntDraft in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks a lot Sean!! You’re amazing!!

Tippman8 in Onstage_1 asks: HAPPY Holidays to you and your family

IndigoAphrodisiac in Onstage_1 asks: Give hugs to all the rest of the cast members from all the fans. You all deserve it

djdeathskiss in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks for doing this chat- now go get some rest!!

sorchafeanor in Onstage_1 asks: You really made Sam feel real to me……..thanks so much

EveElera in Onstage_1 asks: Poor Sean, overloaded with comments. ^-^ (Laughs) Ah, well, you deserve it! You’re a brilliant actor and a wonderful person!

Jordinothepizza in Onstage_1 asks: You seem to be a very nice person, and truly took on the role of Sam….excellent job. Oustanding. Seeing your performance on screen was the highlight of seeing ROTK

beavis99999 in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks for being cool and stuff

Reesh2009 in Onstage_1 asks: BE SURE TO TELL BILLY I SAID HI!! AND I STILL LOVE YOU!!!

lotr311 in Onstage_1 asks: thank you soooooooo much for being here

Zeosoez in Onstage_1 asks: Your performance is nothing short of amazing. We all hope you take home that Oscar. All the best in the future, we all love you!

Panamapk in Onstage_1 asks: We will miss seeing you on the big screen as Sam! Good luck in your future projects! You are great!

x4kowal in Onstage_1 asks: you’re the greatest!!!!

Vssangel1 in Onstage_1 asks: Sean I hope you win an Oscar

southernbelle_23 in Onstage_1 asks: merry christmas and happy new year, sean!

Dejavu_85 in Onstage_1 asks: I loved the movie, and good luck with everything!! Merry Christmas!!

DomEntDraft in Onstage_1 asks: Thanks a lot!! Sam is the true hero of the trilogy! Thanks a lot for bringing him to life!!

WhereTheySellPints in Onstage_1 asks: Tell Billy the wacky loons in Alberta send him a huge hello from mario’s! Thanks Sean you rock!

Arwen_Undomiel_8708 in Onstage_1 asks: Hope you get an Oscar nod, I can’t think of anyone who deserves it more than you!

GildorInglorion1 in Onstage_1 asks: Have a safe Christmas and a Happy New Year!!

HappySmileyFaceOfDoom in Onstage_1 asks: Yeah, you deserve the Best Actor Oscar for your role as Sam!

MunggyWunggy2 in Onstage_1 asks: i can picture it now, you accepting the oscar with “rudy” playing in the background.. it’s your theme

Jenn_Thor in Onstage_1 asks: Well i gotta go! HOpe you have a great Christmas and New Year! God Bless.

GildorInglorion1 in Onstage_1 asks: (laughs) be sure to tell Dom I say hi!!!

Sarumanly in Onstage_1 asks: The “S__G ME BILLY!” girls say Happy Holidays!!!

FoolofATook04 in Onstage_1 asks: Sam was one of the best highlights in movies, you are truly a Hobbit

IndigoAphrodisiac in Onstage_1 asks: True… very wonderful person. And I don’t know what kind of holidays you celebrate, but I hope they’re good and full of.. what was that? REST!!

ChristmasSamweis in Onstage_1 asks: Sean we love all your work , thanks for coming and answering questions tonight. You rock!

ElberethElendil2 in Onstage_1 asks: MERRY CHRISTMAS! Thanx again!

lotrfanbabi in Onstage_1 asks: your talents absolutely stun me!!! your so amazing! thanks for doing a wonderful job as sam!

I love the site, it’s been my primary LotR news site since mid-2000. Merry Christmas!
Joel