Get your tickets to Tolkien today!
Join us in our forums!
Check out on Twitter!
Join us on Instagram

Latest Tweets


  2. In 1918 JRR Tolkien had been put in command of an outpost & promoted to lieutenant, which allowed his wife Edith to…

  3. An amazing Baggins Birthday Bash with so many fans LIVE in person sharing what they are looking most forward to on…

In search of a better George R.R. Martin comparison

June 22, 2013 at 6:09 am by Demosthenes  - 

Pages: 1 2 3 4

What are we left with?

George RR Martin by Karolina Webb.

George RR Martin by Karolina Webb.

So, maybe, if you took the political intrigue of Wurts or Rawn, mashed it with the anti-heroic tropes of Donaldson or Moorcock and added the deft world-building and earn-your-happy-ending twists of Tad Williams then sprinkled it all with the non-magical mundanity of Peake, then you might get George RR Martin.

But, between you, me and the wall, that’s just silly. Isn’t it?

And that’s how daft most comparisons are. Because on one hand nothing is ever exact unless it’s itself, and on the other the sort of mash-up I described above is worse than useless.

The irony is that I don’t think that calling George RR Martin the American Tolkien does him any great service (but we all know it makes a great headline!). In fact it’s unhelpful because it’s so reductive that it creates false expectations.

He’s no more that than he is the male Melanie Rawn, or Mervyn Peake with a faster-moving plot, or…

You get the picture.

He’s his own author creating his own stories in his own particular way, and doing it quite successfully to boot (if a little slower than many might prefer).

Demosthenes has been an incredibly nerdy staff member at since 2001. The views in this article are his own, and do not necessarily represent those of other TORn staff.

Posted in Fellowship of the Ring, Green Books, J.R.R. Tolkien, Lord of the Rings, LotR Books, Return of the King, The Two Towers, Tolkien on June 22, 2013 by

The Floor Plan from WETA Workshop

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *