Get your tickets to Tolkien today!
Join us in our forums!
Get your tickets to Tolkien today!
Join us on Instagram

Latest Tweets

  1. TheOneRing.net
    TheOneRing.net: Amazon: but we just paid a billion dollars for the rights! https://t.co/HByX7dEtZa

  2. TheOneRing.net
    TheOneRing.net: Security cam footage proves that Gandalf is officially a disturber of the peace! #Happy4thofJuly https://t.co/xf2UgGtJOc

  3. TheOneRing.net
    TheOneRing.net: JRR Tolkien is like “I know a place” and it’s the same corner of the same pub every time https://t.co/hBaXoR81m2

News Alerts

Get emailed with every new post!

Hobbiton set report spoiler analysis

October 31, 2011 at 9:15 am by Demosthenes  - 

So the first set report from the Hobbit is here — and it’s from on location in Hobbiton (well, Matamata). If, like me, you want to know what the obscure (and not so obscure) hints mean for the script, this is the place for you.

If not, best go elsewhere — we’re about to delve headlong into SPOILER country!

So, start to get interesting when Quint starts talking about running into Elijah Wood on set.

Munching on jellied toast, Frodo Baggins sauntered out and hopped down the steps leading to the mailbox, grabbed some mail and headed back inside… I don’t want to spoil too much, but I can say that Frodo is part of the connecting tissue between The Hobbit and Fellowship of the Ring.

Now, we already knew that Wood was returning for The Hobbit. The following two snippets is where the gears started turning in my head.

…the next shot was an over the shoulder on Elijah Wood hammering a sign up on Bag End’s front gate: “No Admittance Except On Party Business.”

So we’re at the Long Expected Party, and Frodo is trying to keep all Bilbo’s unwelcome visitors at bay. So far, so easy. And then:

Their conversation is about Gandalf and if Bilbo thinks Gandalf will show up. Bilbo says “He wouldn’t miss a chance to let off his whiz-poppers. He’ll put on quite a show, you’ll see,” and Frodo grins, saying he’s going to go surprise him and bounds off down the path like a kid at Christmas.

Seems to be a prelude scene that leads up to the one in Fellowship with Frodo waiting for Gandalf to arrive in his cart full of fireworks.

How is this being used, though?

It’s my understanding this shot will transition to “60 Years Earlier” with Young Bilbo sitting in front of Bag End contently smoking a pipe and casually blowing smoke rings as Gandalf comes along and presents him with his adventure.

The Rings tie-in and the fact the link is occurring from the Long-expected Party back to An Unexpected Party is quite a neat piece of synchronicity. Thinking about this transition — and how it might work — triggered a very specific memory from Fellowship of the Rings.

It’s that initial scene where Ian Holm is sitting at his drawing table and making the front cover of his book. He writes “There and back again, A Hobbit’s tale, by Bilbo Baggins. By Bilbo Baggins.”

That’s the title of the second Hobbit film, not the first… but still pretty neat.

Now, all us massive Tolkien nerds (what do you mean you’re not one?) know that Bilbo had begun but not finished his book (how else could have Merry snuck a peek at it) at the time he left for Rivendell.

Still, I reckon that the transition will occur through that drawing of the title page.

Because in Fellowship, Holm’s very next line is “And now, where to begin?”

And I bet the answer will be perhaps the most important line ever written in fantasy: “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.”

And then we’ll transition back 60 years…

What do you reckon? Share your thoughts and speculations on our message boards or visit our Hobbit chat!

Posted in Hobbit Movie, Uncategorized on October 31, 2011 by
Hobbiton set report spoiler analysis | Discuss

Order the Gollum Enraged - Click Here

36 responses to “Hobbiton set report spoiler analysis”

  1. Guest says:

    Way to misspell the ‘most important line ever written in fantasy’. Not that I am surprised. This site is riddled with typos. Still, interesting article.

  2. Guest says:

    Way to misspell the ‘most important line ever written in fantasy’. Not that I am surprised. This site is riddled with typos. Still, interesting article.

  3. Guest says:

    Way to misspell the ‘most important line ever written in fantasy’. Not that I am surprised. This site is riddled with typos. Still, interesting article.

  4. Guest says:

    Way to misspell the ‘most important line ever written in fantasy’. Not that I am surprised. This site is riddled with typos. Still, interesting article.

  5. Mughi says:

    “In a WHOLE”?????

  6. Mughi says:

    “In a WHOLE”?????

  7. Mughi says:

    “In a WHOLE”?????

  8. Mughi says:

    “In a WHOLE”?????

  9. WBrisky says:

    A hole, not a whole.

  10. WBrisky says:

    A hole, not a whole.

  11. WBrisky says:

    A hole, not a whole.

  12. WBrisky says:

    A hole, not a whole.

  13. Dumb668 says:

    “In a HOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.” not “In a WHOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.”and you call yourself fans… 😛

  14. Dumb668 says:

    “In a HOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.” not “In a WHOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.”and you call yourself fans… 😛

  15. Dumb668 says:

    “In a HOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.” not “In a WHOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.”and you call yourself fans… 😛

  16. Dumb668 says:

    “In a HOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.” not “In a WHOLE in the ground there lived a hobbit.”and you call yourself fans… 😛

  17. LaurieMann says:

    I think that would be a fine transition between the LOTR movies and The Hobbit movies.

  18. LaurieMann says:

    I think that would be a fine transition between the LOTR movies and The Hobbit movies.

  19. LaurieMann says:

    I think that would be a fine transition between the LOTR movies and The Hobbit movies.

  20. LaurieMann says:

    I think that would be a fine transition between the LOTR movies and The Hobbit movies.

  21. Thethedew says:

    Presumably Ian Holm will be the voice of the Narrator throughout the films.  There is a lot of fun text which is delivered in Tolkien’s own voice in The Hobbit, and it seems only appropriate that Sir Ian will be delivering it (it would be pretty hard to adapt into standard dialogue – and it would be a huge shame to loose it too).

  22. Thethedew says:

    Presumably Ian Holm will be the voice of the Narrator throughout the films.  There is a lot of fun text which is delivered in Tolkien’s own voice in The Hobbit, and it seems only appropriate that Sir Ian will be delivering it (it would be pretty hard to adapt into standard dialogue – and it would be a huge shame to loose it too).

  23. Thethedew says:

    Presumably Ian Holm will be the voice of the Narrator throughout the films.  There is a lot of fun text which is delivered in Tolkien’s own voice in The Hobbit, and it seems only appropriate that Sir Ian will be delivering it (it would be pretty hard to adapt into standard dialogue – and it would be a huge shame to loose it too).

  24. Jandy says:

    you’re right… that has to be the next shot: “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.” – That would be AWESOME

  25. Jandy says:

    you’re right… that has to be the next shot: “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.” – That would be AWESOME

  26. Jandy says:

    you’re right… that has to be the next shot: “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.” – That would be AWESOME

  27. Jandy says:

    you’re right… that has to be the next shot: “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.” – That would be AWESOME

  28. Yavanna says:

    I’ve thought all along that Wood’s part would include Bilbo’s book. Your conjecture is intelligent and insightful. Of course, Peter/Fran/Phillipa could still surprise us all, couldn’t they? ;~)

  29. Yavanna says:

    I’ve thought all along that Wood’s part would include Bilbo’s book. Your conjecture is intelligent and insightful. Of course, Peter/Fran/Phillipa could still surprise us all, couldn’t they? ;~)

  30. Yavanna says:

    I’ve thought all along that Wood’s part would include Bilbo’s book. Your conjecture is intelligent and insightful. Of course, Peter/Fran/Phillipa could still surprise us all, couldn’t they? ;~)

  31. Yavanna says:

    I’ve thought all along that Wood’s part would include Bilbo’s book. Your conjecture is intelligent and insightful. Of course, Peter/Fran/Phillipa could still surprise us all, couldn’t they? ;~)

  32. Lizzie says:

    Damn!! I can’t resist reading such articles but then ,afterwards I immediatley wish I hadn’t!!I’m so desperate to return to middle earth and want to devour every little snippet of news and information re.the movies but really I know it’ll be better in the end to wait til Dec 2012!! Its a dilemma!!

  33. Lizzie says:

    Damn!! I can’t resist reading such articles but then ,afterwards I immediatley wish I hadn’t!!I’m so desperate to return to middle earth and want to devour every little snippet of news and information re.the movies but really I know it’ll be better in the end to wait til Dec 2012!! Its a dilemma!!

  34. Lizzie says:

    Damn!! I can’t resist reading such articles but then ,afterwards I immediatley wish I hadn’t!!I’m so desperate to return to middle earth and want to devour every little snippet of news and information re.the movies but really I know it’ll be better in the end to wait til Dec 2012!! Its a dilemma!!

  35. Lizzie says:

    Damn!! I can’t resist reading such articles but then ,afterwards I immediatley wish I hadn’t!!I’m so desperate to return to middle earth and want to devour every little snippet of news and information re.the movies but really I know it’ll be better in the end to wait til Dec 2012!! Its a dilemma!!

Leave a Reply