[Annatar] hello, we’re trying to connect a 2nd machine right now, this is paul, Kris will also be here, but not jeff
[Gorlab] This is Kris again, and I am now Balrog backwards…
[Gorlab] Today’s lesson is full of perilous phonology, dangerous diphthongs, and phunny phrases….stay tuned…
[Gorlab] 8 O’clock….
[Gorlab] The ring of power is no trifle……or truffle…now the ring of Truffle is VERY tasty…
[jincey] mmmmm truffles
[Gorlab] Gandalf is no ordinary wizard, but part of a special group of powers…..like Silent Bob has in Mallrats….
[Annatar] elen sila lumenn’ omentielvo
[[Gorlab] Elen Sila Lumenn Omentielvo fellow Elvish language lovers!
[Gorlab] Today’s lesson oh fair people, shall cover some of the most basic principles of Elvish, which are instrumental in speaking both Quenya and Sindarin…
[Gorlab] Elvish has a common source.
[Gorlab] It is known as Primitive Elvish (or Primitive Quendian if you like)
[Annatar] fortunately, the Professor (tolkien) used essentially the same rules for “spelling” or transliterating both Sindarin and Quenya
[Gorlab] Exactly – owing to their common source…
[Gorlab] the first idea is that of the letter “c”
[Gorlab] Lots of early Elvish used the letter “K”
[Annatar] Presumably, they were both written in Tenwar in the “source documents” but in differing modes, however, when written in Roman alphabet, the same rules apply
[Gorlab] But the Professor wanted to make Quenya seem a lot more Latinized…
[Gorlab] so he adopted “c”
[Annatar] Tolkien decided that K was “uncouth”
[Gorlab] “c” is ALWAYS pronounced like “k”
[Annatar] unless combines with H
[Annatar] in which case youget the ch of German “ich”
[Gorlab] so, for instance Celeborn (husband of Galadriel) is pronouced “Keleborn”, never “Seleborn”
[Gorlab] Next is “qu”. “Qu” is the preffered spelling, never “q” by itself
[Demcoffee] it took me ages to catch onto the pronunciation sublties in the names
[Gorlab] Only Tolkien’s earliest languages used “q” by itself.
[Gorlab] Next is “X” instead of “ks” as in “Helcaraxe”
[Annatar] However, it is not the Q of “iraq” but pronounced qu
[Gorlab] next is “N”
[Maeglin_Lomion] Pronunciation question: “Fingolfin”…is it Fing(ng as in sing) -ol-fin, or Fin-gol-fin?
[Elaran] is not gandalf from the mannish tongues?
[Gorlab] Gandalf is actually an old Norse word from the icelandic eddas…
[Elaran] indeed, just curious
[Gorlab] I believe he was a dwarf in that story…
[Annatar] I believe that it’s fin-GOL-fin
[Maeglin_Lomion] Thank you
[Ks] question ?
[Gorlab] Yes?
[Ks] i live in israel.. does the elvish dudes got the het letter?
[Ks] i mean
[Ks] can they say
[Ks] het
[Ks] ç
[Ks] cant say it
[Annatar] pronouced?
[Ks] in english
[Ks] u dont use that sound
[Ks] AT ALL
[Ks] so its hard to pronounce
[Annatar] arabic?
[Ks] hebrew
[Gorlab] you are reffering to the semitic\/arabic idea of the sound in the back of the throat?
[Annatar] no, do they use it in arabic?
[Ks] yes they use it in arabic 2
[Gorlab] as in chutzpah?
[Ks] ken
[Ks] yes
[Gorlab] Not exactly…
[Ks] yes
[Ks] the first letter
[Annatar] what context?
[Ks] the first sound
[Ks] of chutzpah
[Ks] chu
[Annatar] that is the ch of evlish approximately
[Ks] okay
[Gorlab] Elves DO pronounce “hy” as an “ich-laut” and “ht” as an “ach-laut”
[Mo] is it kind of like a spitting sound in the back of your throat Ks?
[Gorlab] It’s more of a germanic idea than the hebrew sound…
[Annatar] ich is unvoiced, ach is voiced
[Gorlab] The Elvish is a similar sound, but more in the front of the mouth…
[Annatar] let’s talk about my fave — “dh”
[Annatar] TH in English is pronouced 2 ways
[Gorlab] Ah! DH…found all over Sindarin…
[Annatar] in Elvish TH is voiceless “”thing”
[Annatar] DH is voiced “them”
[Gorlab] not as in “thought”
[Annatar] no
[Maeglin_Lomion] Aredhel – “soft” TH?
[Figgy] as in…?
[Annatar] D was Sometimes used for DH in Tolkiens early writings
[Gorlab] a good word seen in the LOTR movie I believe is Galadhrim…
[Figgy] oooh…cool
[Annatar] but he later smitched to DH for clarity in LOTR
[Annatar] in the 1st Editon of LOTR it’s “Galadrim”
[Elaran] interesting
[Annatar] but he later changed it to “GalaDHrim”
[Gorlab] Try the soft “th” sound followed by the trilled “r”
[Dsthenes] ah, interesting
[Gorlab] it’s a beautiful sound…
[Figgy] it sounds very nice \ud83d\ude42
[GuestLastar] makes it easier to pronounce
[Annatar] “galad” is “light” “galadh” is tree
[Dsthenes] galathrim?
[Annatar] Galadriel has the “light” element like Gil Galad
[Elaran] Haldir is about the only person to pronounce Galadhrim correctly (in the extended version)
[Annatar] he’s a good elf
[Gorlab] Yes, Elaran!
[Elaran] Gimli mutilates it \ud83d\ude09
[Gorlab] Gimli WOULD though…
[Elaran] sorry to interupt!
[GuestLastar] ah. evil dwarves
[Annatar] GalaDHrim has the “tree” element
[Ks] tree?
[Annatar] tree people
[Elaran] galadh= tree galad = light
[Gorlab] The Galadhrim are the peoples of Lothlorien…
[Gorlab] Of the trees…
[Annatar] A great name with DH is Maedhros form the Silmarillion
[Maeglin_Lomion] That is a beautiful-sounding name.
[Annatar] ’cause, he also has the AE sound
[Gorlab] which brings us to long and short vowels…
[Dsthenes] Now I’m going to have to reform a heap of name pronunciations again. \ud83d\ude42
[Gorlab] whenever you see a vowel by itself…
[Annatar] it’s difficult to pronounce but it’s like “I” in English
[Gorlab] it is pronounced “short”
[Lefolas] how many times have you guys done all of this? teaching people elvish
[Gorlab] but when you see a vowel with an accent mrk above it…
[2[Gorlab] that vowel becomes long…
[Figgy] example?
[Gorlab] short “A” is pronounced like “Han Solo”. when we first meet him in Star Wars…
[Gorlab] long “A” os pronounced as in “father”
[Figgy] I see
[Indil] so, the circumflex accent always indicates a long vowel?
[Gorlab] Yes…
[Annatar] yes, but it’s also used for visual effect in non-Elven tongues
[Lady_Samwise] hte a in father and in han sound the same though
[Legolas17] ok my question is ok now…. i guess
[Legolas17] the double l, like in ‘mellon’ -friend
[Maeglin_Lomion] So â would be pronounced like the a in “day?”
[Annatar] such as Adunaic and Khuxdul — Dwarvish
[samgamgee7] yea, i got lost on that one too, Lady_Samwise…
[Elaran] they should sound the same, the only difference is the length
[Lady_Samwise] \ud83d\ude42
[samgamgee7] a lil further clarification on that one?
[Figgy] yeah
[Legolas17] is it not pronounced like in the back of the throat h
[Figgy] their length is different
[Legolas17] ?
[Lady_Samwise] oh IC…
[Figgy] maybe “cat” and “father”
[samgamgee7] ahhh, ok : )
[Gorlab] “Han” is more like “hand” than the “a” in “father”
[Annatar] for the AY in day you need EI
[Indil] I think like the a in man rather than han
[Lia_the_vampire] im a little confused
[Maeglin_Lomion] Thank you.
[Annatar] Okay from the top
[Gorlab] “man” will do fine…
[Annatar] A is the European “a”
[[Gorlab] short “a” is like “man”
[Gorlab] long “a” is like “Father”
[Elaran] as in british english? or are we refering to other celtic or Norse languages?
[Annatar] “E” is the Euro “E” not the American one
[Annatar] Italian is a good guide to Elvish vowels
[Maeglin_Lomion] Example? I’m American
[CloakedGuest thinks to pronounce the majority of vowels as they would be in Spanish
[Lia_the_vampire] im a vampire
[Gorlab] short “i” is like “pit”
[Annatar] and long is like Pete
[Gorlab] long “i” is like the one in “machine”
[Annatar] O is like “Lore”
[[Gorlab] short “o” is like “box”
[Gorlab] long “o” is like “sore”
[liam] We’re talking Sindarin, right?
[Annatar] but not “Open”
[Annatar] same for Q and S
[Gorlab] these pronunciations are nearly universal for elvish…
[Annatar] Different in Tengwar, Same in the Roman Characters
[liam] Q doesn’t make as much difference between long and short vowels, I understand.
[Annatar] not really, but the spelling in English takes care of that
[hobbit] wut does Falchrist mean?
[hobbit] short i, not long
[Gorlab] Sounds Old english…Annatar?
[Annatar] Coast Cleaver?
[Elaran] it means something on the order of “deep cutting ravine” or possibly “deep cutting cleaver”
[Annatar] Falas — coast, Orcrist Orc -cleaver
[Eressea] Most of the r’s seem to be trilled.
[liam] and hold the second o a little longer.
[Gorlab] actually, the “r’ must be trilled in all positions…
[CloakedGuest] Also, from Old English I believe, the “Gan” part means “to wander” … for I am descended from someone called Ganger.
[Mo] what is a trilled r?
[Eressea] Standard Elvish pronunciation to trill r’s?
[Elaran] tis what gives the language part of its flavor =) Tolkien seemed to dislike the uvelar r that the french use
[Salquendor] from what i understand quenya vowels are like romance language vowels, from the site it seems to be all of my spanish vowels and the quenya vowels match (short form)
[liam] trilled r’s are a bit like Spanish rr
[Annatar] it can be tappped, bur it is never the retoflex R of American English
[Guest1] whats hello in elvish?
[Indil] so the trilled r Ian McKellen uses to say “mordor” in the films is correct?
[[Gorlab] Yes, it is standard, although you don’t have to get excited like Charro on the Love Boat…
[Brandalf85] Hello in elvish is “vendui”
[Brandalf85] well that is “Greetings”
[Guest1] oh thanks
[Gorlab] ABSOLUTELY!!! One of Ian McKellan’s great pronunciations…
[liam] Yes, McKellen gets that dead to rights.
[Annatar] Tolkien said that he believed that Italian Vowels were the closest to Quenya
[Eressea] Who’s excited?
[2[Guest1] how do you prononce it?
[Brandalf85] Ven Doo
[Gorlab] Or, “Aiya!” which means “hail!” or “Greetings!”
[Annatar] The Sindarin Y however seems to be Welsh
[Guest1] cool
[Brandalf85] yes Gor
[Salquendor] annatar, i dont know much italian, but they are close to spanish short vowels correct?
[[Brandalf85] Mckellen got Gandalfs voice from Tolkiens
[Indil] It cstainly sounds more impressive that way \ud83d\ude42
[liam] the Sindarin Y is like German u-umlat.
[Brandalf85] i have some of tolkien reading on tape
[[Gorlab] Also, the fomal greeting is “Elen Sila Lumenn Omentielvo”
[Elaran] vendu? would we not see something from the roots _suilanna_ or _suila_?
[Guest1] is namarie goodbye?
[Brandalf85] yes guest
[liam] Say “ee” and then round your lips like you would for saying “o”.
[Brandalf85] actually its “Farewell”
[Annatar] Since Sindarin was modelled on Welsh to a certain degree, this makes sense
[Gorlab] Namarie is indeed “Good-bye”
[Gorlab] from Na, meaning “is”
[Brandalf85] i have a website that gives like a whole list of elvish phrases
[Guest1] whats how are you?
[Gorlab] and “marie” meaning “it is good”
[Elaran] and Navaer is the deduced sindarin counterpart
[Gorlab] correct
[hobbit] namarie means be in good health, if i am correct
[Brandalf85] http:\/\/www.grey-company.org\/Circle\/language\/phrase.htm
[Brandalf85] there
[Elaran] gah no!
[Brandalf85] for elvish phrases
[Gorlab] “be good” would be a possible literal translation for “Namarie”
[Eressea] I was under the impression that Grey Company Elvish was fan-devised.
[Annatar] okay, back to vowels
[Gorlab] I’m sure there are others…
[Annatar] AE and AI are very close
[Elaran] it is Eressea, its devised out of both Sindarin and Quenya for roleplaying purposes
[Elaran] hence my personal distaste for it
[Figgy] how is Eressea pronounced?
[Brandalf85] Eres Say
[Brandalf85] i believe
[[Eressea] Er – ess – ay – ah
[Brandalf85] or not
[Figgy] ah
[Figgy] good
[Eressea] It’s spelled Eressëa with the funny accent on the third ‘e’.
[Elaran] diaresis \ud83d\ude09
[[Annatar] A is the “father” A, I is the sound in “meet” together you get “I” the english pronoun
[Gorlab] With the accent on the “ay” sound…
[Figgy] I’ve been saying it right then
[Eressea] Or as Eresseä if you’re not talking about the island, but the word.
[Gorlab] a diaresis is used to 1:
[Gorlab] Clarify seperate pronunciation of vowels
[Gorlab] 2. for a final “e”
[Annatar] E is the A of “lady”
[Figgy] I see
[Gorlab] or 3 for vowel combinations.
[Eressea] Diaresis is the two-dots thing?
[Annatar] like Spanish Italian etc.
[Gorlab] two dots thingy, yup!
[Annatar] two dots, two sounds
[GuestLastar] oh. what is the pronounciation difference between ë and e
[Gorlab] “au” os pronounced as in “cow”
[Gorlab] Try pronouncing the God “Aule”
[Eressea] GuestLastar, iirc “ë” tends to take on the “ay” sound.
[GuestLastar] thnx
[Indil] Like “owly?
[Brandalf85] lol
[Annatar] We used to call the “dotted” E “Feanorian” it jest means to separate thevowles
[Brandalf85] i always pronounced Aule like “oo lee”
[Gorlab] Ow-leh
[Brandalf85] for some reason
[Gorlab] “eu” is pronounced like the name of the Peter Gabriel album “so”
[CloakedGuest thinks of the word lenguëta in Spanish as an example of how diaresis changes sound similar to what Eressea says
[Eressea] I was doing “Oh – lay” but I suppose, given “S ow – ron”, it should be ow-leh…
[Annatar] diaresis is used the same way that is is in
[[Mo] would eu be like the french word for water then?
[Annatar] French E.G. “noel”
[Annatar] yes
[Gorlab] Sow-rahn, as in “cow-rahn”, Dark Lord of Cattle…
[Eressea] lolol
[Maeglin_Lomion] \ud83d\ude42 Gorlab
[Gorlab] “iu” is pronounced like “yoo”
[Annatar] in lieu of
[Annatar] for example
[Gorlab] and, the skate-punk’s fave: “oi” is pronounced as in “toy”
[Dsthenes] heh
[GuestLastar] umm… is there a between in meaning betwen, for example, faire and fairë becuz of the ë?
[GuestLastar] *difference
[Annatar] not to my knowlege
[Gorlab] final “e” always recieves the diaresis…
[Gorlab] it really just means that it is always pronounced seperately
[Gorlab] in fact, you almost don’t need it…
[Annatar] speaking of stress . . .
[Annatar] Who here knows how it works?
[Gorlab] Which sylablle gets the “oomph”?
[Mo] is it the middle syllable?
[Elaran] I do
[Elaran] though it is somewhat complex
[Maeglin_Lomion] 2nd out of 4th, if 4 syllables?
[Indil] In Welsh it would be the middle…
[Gorlab] Well, what if you only have on sylablle?
[Eressea] Elvish is inflexive, is it not?
[Elaran] then it falls on the one \ud83d\ude09
[Annatar] basically, if there are more than one syllable, the 2nd or 3rd to last gets it
[Gorlab] Two syllables will ALWAYS be on the first syllable as well…
[Figgy] we got lots of training on stressed syllables in school
[Gorlab] EXCEPT for…
[Gorlab] one word: “Ava”
[Gorlab] it means “Don’t!”
[Eressea] Ava, as in Avatar?
[Indil] or Avari, the refusers?
[Annatar] different language
[Gorlab] In Elvish, Avatar would be “Don’t King”
[Annatar] yes
[Gorlab] Avari! Yes!
[Annatar] no
[Annatar] lol
[Eressea] Perhapts it’s Av-atar, rather than ava-tar, then..
[Maeglin_Lomion] Haldir always seems to be pronounced Hal-DEER. Would that be an exception, or is everyone pronouncing it wrong?
[Elaran] it should be on the first
[Annatar] I think it’s a mistake, and it’s also why he seems a little annoyed
[Indil] lol!
[Elaran] the only time I can think of where one _might_ place it finally would be if the word incorporated a circumflex (possibly to mark it as irregular stress)
[Eressea] So how does one pronounce “Ancalagoth” in terms of stress?
[Annatar] AnCALagoth
[Annatar] not AncalAgoth
[Gorlab] Well, here’s where our idea of long and short vowels comes in handy…
[Annatar] and single and double consonants
[[Eressea] So like Caribbean, then. \ud83d\ude42
[Gorlab] If a word has 3 or more sylablles…
[Gorlab] many are stressed on the second-to-last sylablle…
[Gorlab] BUT
[Indil] so, MinDOLluin? Instead of MINdolluin?
[Gorlab] if this syllable is SHORT
[Annatar] if the 2nd to last Syllable has a “short” vowel or is separated from the last one by a single consonant, then it’s too “weak to get the stress
[Gorlab] (Sure Oh cloaked one)
[Gorlab] A short syllable is one that
[Annatar] in which case stress moves to the 3rd to last syllable
[CloakedGuest] (thank you Gorlab)
[Gorlab] 1. Contains no long vowel and
[Gorlab] 2 is followed by only one consonant or no consonant at all
[Annatar] in technical terms the 3rd to last syllable is the “antepenultimate”
[Gorlab] If this sylablle is SHORT
[Gorlab] then the 3rd-to-last sylablle gets the stress…
[Eressea] What a word, “antepenultimate”…
[Elaran] lol tis better than antidisestablishmentarianism \ud83d\ude09
[Eressea] Ante-pen-ultimate… that would be before-almost-last, yes?
[Eressea] Hence, third-last.
[Maeglin_Lomion] An example of this? I’m confuzzled……
[Gorlab] Annatar – an example?
[Annatar] ThangorOdrim
[Gorlab] As opposed to..
[Gorlab] ThangORodrim…
[Annatar] DR is bigger separation than G
[Eressea] Then GonDOlin over GONdolin?
[ohtar_i_anar] is there any stress?
[CloakedGuest] In fact, I’ve been saying GondoLIN.
[CloakedGuest] \ud83d\ude42
[ohtar_i_anar] there is no mark
[Annatar] no, ND vs. L
[Maeglin_Lomion] So have I. \ud83d\ude42
[Indil] So Mindolluin, above, should really be MidolLUIN?
[Annatar] LL
[Indil] *MindolLUIN
[Annatar] MindOLLuin
[Indil] oh dear. This is very confusing :-0
[ohtar_i_anar] actually, when I say it, I find myself saying gonDOlin
[Annatar] not the boat
[ohtar_i_anar] I know
[Gorlab] This completes my time here in the Hall, thanks for listening…be here next week for more – Annatar might stay a bit…
[Annatar] or, rather like GONDola instead of gondOla
[Eressea] Thanks, Gorlab. \ud83d\ude42
[Indil] Thank you gorlab. This has been very helpful!
[Maeglin_Lomion] Thanks, Gorlab.
[Annatar] follow the consonants, and when they don’s help. look for accents
[Mo] Thank you Gorlab – cant’ be here usually bacause of work, but i appreciate it
[Pippin] ok, so what form of Elvish are we learning exactly?
[furryfootses] where can i get all the info that i missed since these lessons started
[
[Eressea] On the site, furryfootses, I believe there are logs…
[Annatar] The chat as a whole will try to cover Quenya and Sindarin
[Pippin] ok, cool \ud83d\ude42
[Annatar] However, they overlap considerably
[Pippin is learning Quenya, but it kinda confuses her as the lesson planner uses big words
[furryfootses] thanks, eressea and annatar
[Annatar] if anyone has any germaine questions please ask, otherwise, my fingers hurt
[Legolas17] how is ll pronounced, as in ‘mellon’?
[Pippin] like a normal l
[Pippin] not like spanish
[Mo] Do you know any examples for long and short E? i’m not familiar with more european styles
Gorlab has quit IRC (Quit: Leaving)
[Legolas17] i read somewhere that it was pronounced like a harsh h in the back of the throat
[Annatar] thank you every one I’ll see y’all later
[Pippin] somewhere must have been referring to Gandalf’s pronunciation of the word in the Bakshi edition of LOTR
[Indil] Thank you so much Annatar!
[Maeglin_Lomion] Thank you, Annatar.
[Eressea] Thank you, Annatar. \ud83d\ude42
[Legolas17] thanks Annatar
[Dsthenes] thanks, Annatar. \ud83d\ude42
[Mo] Thank you Annatar
[GuestLastar] thnx annatar
[Pippin] thank you Annatar<\/p>\n
\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
[Annatar] hello, we’re trying to connect a 2nd machine right now, this is paul, Kris will also be…<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":17,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"inline_featured_image":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_publicize_message":"","jetpack_publicize_feature_enabled":true,"jetpack_social_post_already_shared":false,"jetpack_social_options":{"image_generator_settings":{"template":"highway","default_image_id":0,"font":"","enabled":false},"version":2},"jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[138],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-25539","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-old-special-reports"],"aioseo_notices":[],"jetpack_publicize_connections":[],"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","jetpack_shortlink":"https:\/\/wp.me\/p1tLoH-6DV","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/25539","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/17"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=25539"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/25539\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=25539"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=25539"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.theonering.net\/torwp\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=25539"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}