Support - A not for profit fan community!
Join us in our 24 Hour Chatroom!
LEGO Lord of the Rings Collection
Thranduil Statue

Ringer Reviews - The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug

Letter of Name/Alias: A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | V | W | X | Y | Z

Ringer Review - NAME

Ranger of Dunland

Date Posted: 2014-01-14
Tolkien Fan Level: 7
Film Format Seen? 3D 48 fps
Will view again in a different format? Yes

Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings films had their fair share of faults and blemishes, but they were nonetheless masterpieces in filmmaking. While I still cringe at some changes, I challenge anyone to find a 10 minute segment of those films lacking respect and care in the filmmaking. Every sequence of those films had, more or less, a sense of dignity to it. Those moments are few and far between in "The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug." Frequently, moments came across as contrived, awkward, or even downright silly. They were moments that if written out on a web forum, one would think were part of a spoof, a How-Not-To-Make-The-Hobbit fanvid. For example, in The Fellowship of the Ring, Aragorn takes on almost 100 Uruk-Hai in the film's climax. It is a fantastic action sequence, and the scene scores a perfect balance between making the character believable and still amaze the audience with this warrior's ability to accomplish what they know they could. In The Hobbit: DoS, almost every action scene (elves are the biggest culprits here) loses the audience as this world looks less and less like Tolkien's and more and more like Marvel's (although that's an unfair slam to recent Marvel movies). This lack of dignity is the first major problem of the film, encompassing many more singular issues like some character changes, moments intended for comic relief, and aforementioned action scenes.

The second major problem was the lack of focus. According to the making-of featurettes, LotR used a rule due to the massive source material: Every scene must be A. about Frodo &/or the Ring or B. Have an essential part in the story (e.g. establishing Aragorn as the heir to the throne). "Desolation" obviously used no such rule. Despite the title, the hobbit in the story is really a secondary character and does very little. Even the comparatively better spider sequence makes him merely a helper to the dwarves and elves who tackle the spiders with him.

I could go on about other problems. The overuse of special effects makes the 10+ year old LotR look more realistic overall. And Tolkien purist though I be, I'm not even getting into the dastardly changes from the book. Why not? Because I follow a rule from glumPuddle (from If adapting from a good book, the film must also be good by itself, or it is not a good adaptation. Analyzing the desolation of "The Hobbit" is not worth my time since the film is frankly not terribly likable. While it has a few truly great qualities (see how I scored it), and the acting is outstanding across the board, the film is okay. I suppose it's perhaps on par with or maybe more likable than the Pirates of the Caribbean sequels.

The Ratings
The Other Ratings
Martin Freeman 's performance as Bilbo Baggins?
How would you rate Luke Evan's performance as Bard??
The Overall representation of The Dwarves ?
How would you rate Benedict Cumberbatch's' performance as Smaug?
Ian McKellen's performance as Gandalf?
How would you rate Lee Pace's performance as Thranduil?
How would you rate Orlando Bloom's performance as Legolas?
How would you rate Evangeline Lilly's performance as Tauriel?
How would you rate Stephen Fry's performance as Master of Lake-Town?
Did you think Tauriel was a welcome addition to the film?
How would you rate Beorn?
How would you rate the scene with the Spiders?
How would you rate the imprisonment/escape sequence?
Did you like the Necromancer being discovered by Gandalf as Sauron?
Did the movie fairly portray the character arc of Thorrin?
How would you rate Lake-Town?
How would you rate the burglar interchange between Bilbo and Smaug?
How would you rate revisiting Bree?
How happy are you with the attempts to tie The Hobbit back to the Lord of the Rings?
Did you enjoy seeing Gandalf visit Gol Duldor and The Tombs?
Did you like the splitting of the company of Dwarves?
Did Smaug live up to your expectations?
How would you rate the ending of the movie; in regards to leading well into the next film, and serving as a good ending point.
Is DOS a better film than AUJ?
The overall pace of the film.

Review HomeSubmit a Review